2025This year’s mince pie-oneers.
Andy
- Looks
- 63%
- Sugar
- 63%
- Pastry
- 69%
- Filling
- 73%
- Value
- 71%
- Total
- 68.79%
Best & worst
- Favourite pie
- Morrisons: The Best
- Least favourite pie
- Waitrose: No.1 Brown Butter with Cognac
Awards
The Filling Fanatic award for the most positive filling scoring.
The Budget Buff award for the most positive value scoring.
The Mince Pie Maestro award for the most positive total scoring.
Claire
- Looks
- 68%
- Sugar
- 57%
- Pastry
- 53%
- Filling
- 66%
- Value
- 67%
- Total
- 60.96%
Best & worst
- Favourite pie
- Sainsbury’s: Taste the Difference
- Least favourite pie
- Sainsbury’s
Awards
The Pretty Pie Patron award for the most positive looks scoring.
Dave
- Looks
- 65%
- Sugar
- 48%
- Pastry
- 55%
- Filling
- 60%
- Value
- 54%
- Total
- 56.18%
Best & worst
- Favourite pie
- Waitrose: All Butter
- Least favourite pie
- Sainsbury’s
Awards
The Penny Pincher award for the most critical value scoring.
Emma
- Looks
- 64%
- Sugar
- 67%
- Pastry
- 58%
- Filling
- 72%
- Value
- 65%
- Total
- 65.7%
Best & worst
- Favourite pie
- M&S: Classic
- Least favourite pie
- Asda: OMV!
Awards
The Sweet Tooth award for the most positive sugar scoring.
Euan
- Looks
- 60%
- Sugar
- 58%
- Pastry
- 61%
- Filling
- 66%
- Value
- 59%
- Total
- 61.71%
Best & worst
- Favourite pie
- M&S: Classic
- Least favourite pie
- Asda: OMV!
Fraser
- Looks
- 55%
- Sugar
- 55%
- Pastry
- 60%
- Filling
- 59%
- Value
- 58%
- Total
- 58.25%
Best & worst
- Favourite pie
- M&S: Classic
- Least favourite pie
- Iceland
Heather
- Looks
- 58%
- Sugar
- 56%
- Pastry
- 56%
- Filling
- 57%
- Value
- 56%
- Total
- 56.26%
Best & worst
- Favourite pie
- Morrisons: The Best
- Least favourite pie
- Iceland
Jade
- Looks
- 58%
- Sugar
- 52%
- Pastry
- 67%
- Filling
- 60%
- Value
- 60%
- Total
- 60.61%
Best & worst
- Favourite pie
- M&S: Classic
- Least favourite pie
- Waitrose: No.1 Brown Butter with Cognac
Jeff
- Looks
- 67%
- Sugar
- 45%
- Pastry
- 58%
- Filling
- 63%
- Value
- 61%
- Total
- 58.76%
Best & worst
- Favourite pie
- Sainsbury’s: Taste the Difference
- Least favourite pie
- Asda: OMV!
Awards
The Sugar Skeptic award for the most critical sugar scoring.
Katie
- Looks
- 63%
- Sugar
- 55%
- Pastry
- 64%
- Filling
- 55%
- Value
- 61%
- Total
- 59.03%
Best & worst
- Favourite pie
- M&S: Classic
- Least favourite pie
- Iceland
Katy
- Looks
- 60%
- Sugar
- 51%
- Pastry
- 71%
- Filling
- 38%
- Value
- 65%
- Total
- 54.76%
Best & worst
- Favourite pie
- M&S: Classic
- Least favourite pie
- Iceland
Awards
The Crust Connoisseur award for the most positive pastry scoring.
The Stuffing Scrooge award for the most critical filling scoring.
Kirsty
- Looks
- 60%
- Sugar
- 46%
- Pastry
- 66%
- Filling
- 57%
- Value
- 65%
- Total
- 58.71%
Best & worst
- Favourite pie
- Aldi: Specially Selected
- Least favourite pie
- Waitrose: No.1 Brown Butter with Cognac
Lewis
- Looks
- 62%
- Sugar
- 58%
- Pastry
- 56%
- Filling
- 62%
- Value
- 56%
- Total
- 58.6%
Best & worst
- Favourite pie
- Waitrose: All Butter
- Least favourite pie
- Asda: OMV!
Lucy
- Looks
- 67%
- Sugar
- 52%
- Pastry
- 61%
- Filling
- 62%
- Value
- 67%
- Total
- 60.79%
Best & worst
- Favourite pie
- Morrisons: The Best
- Least favourite pie
- Morrisons
Michelle
- Looks
- 53%
- Sugar
- 46%
- Pastry
- 51%
- Filling
- 52%
- Value
- 60%
- Total
- 51.52%
Best & worst
- Favourite pie
- Morrisons: The Best
- Least favourite pie
- Asda: OMV!
Awards
The Eyesore Evaluator award for the most critical looks scoring.
The Crusty Critic award for the most critical pastry scoring.
The Grinch of the Pies award for the most critical total scoring.
Mike
- Looks
- 59%
- Sugar
- 52%
- Pastry
- 61%
- Filling
- 63%
- Value
- 67%
- Total
- 60.62%
Best & worst
- Favourite pie
- M&S: Classic
- Least favourite pie
- Aldi: Specially Selected
Pete
- Looks
- 58%
- Sugar
- 56%
- Pastry
- 64%
- Filling
- 62%
- Value
- 59%
- Total
- 60.76%
Best & worst
- Favourite pie
- M&S: Classic
- Least favourite pie
- Iceland
Phil
- Looks
- 56%
- Sugar
- 50%
- Pastry
- 52%
- Filling
- 67%
- Value
- 67%
- Total
- 58.76%
Best & worst
- Favourite pie
- Sainsbury’s: Taste the Difference
- Least favourite pie
- Asda: OMV!
Rob
- Looks
- 60%
- Sugar
- 47%
- Pastry
- 63%
- Filling
- 62%
- Value
- 64%
- Total
- 59.6%
Best & worst
- Favourite pie
- Waitrose: All Butter
- Least favourite pie
- Asda: OMV!