2025 Pie Charts – MincePie.fyi

AsdaExceptional

Looks: 64%
Sugar: 48%
Pastry: 51%
Filling: 62%
Value: 48%
Total: 54.91%

See the judges’ scores

Judges	Looks	Sugar	Pastry	Filling	Value	Total
Andy						64.60%
Claire						44.20%
Dave						44.15%
Emma						52.79%
Euan						55.34%
Fraser						46.82%
Heather						65.46%
Jade						60.06%
Jeff						57.16%
Katie						70.79%
Katy						68.07%
Kirsty						64.09%
Lewis						43.30%
Lucy						45.40%
Michelle						64.09%
Mike						54.20%
Pete						47.39%
Phil						54.77%
Rob						40.57%
Total	64%	48%	51%	62%	48%	54.91%

See more of this pie

Morrisons

Looks: 61%
Sugar: 41%
Pastry: 45%
Filling: 47%
Value: 69%
Total: 49.13%

See the judges’ scores

Judges	Looks	Sugar	Pastry	Filling	Value	Total
Andy						76.25%
Claire						41.08%
Dave						52.61%
Emma						71.14%
Euan						48.58%
Fraser						42.27%
Heather						60.79%
Jade						52.33%
Jeff						59.66%
Katie						40.57%
Katy						31.93%
Kirsty						35.79%
Lewis						42.16%
Lucy						23.12%
Michelle						41.02%
Mike						71.42%
Pete						45.96%
Phil						47.95%
Rob						48.80%
Total	61%	41%	45%	47%	69%	49.13%

See more of this pie

AsdaOMV!

Looks: 45%
Sugar: 34%
Pastry: 35%
Filling: 34%
Value: 41%
Total: 35.95%

The Wallet Waster award for the worst value.

See the judges’ scores

Judges	Looks	Sugar	Pastry	Filling	Value	Total
Andy						53.41%
Claire						66.53%
Dave						29.66%
Emma						37.10%
Euan						25.11%
Fraser						34.26%
Heather						39.66%
Jade						40.34%
Jeff						31.99%
Katie						32.33%
Katy						27.61%
Kirsty						33.18%
Lewis						30.23%
Lucy						51.48%
Michelle						30.79%
Mike						40.57%
Pete						31.36%
Phil						25.68%
Rob						21.70%
Total	45%	34%	35%	34%	41%	35.95%

See more of this pie

Looks: 82%
Sugar: 71%
Pastry: 79%
Filling: 77%
Value: 67%
Total: 75.82%

The Sweet Spot award for the best sugar.

See the judges’ scores

Judges	Looks	Sugar	Pastry	Filling	Value	Total
Andy						88.86%
Claire						81.42%
Dave						58.92%
Emma						74.83%
Euan						77.16%
Fraser						72.56%
Heather						81.70%
Jade						75.97%
Jeff						62.33%
Katie						58.81%
Katy						75.57%
Kirsty						79.49%
Lewis						68.01%
Lucy						100.00%
Michelle						72.05%
Mike						78.32%
Pete						78.86%
Phil						79.43%
Rob						76.31%
Total	82%	71%	79%	77%	67%	75.82%

See more of this pie

WaitroseNo.1 Brown Butter with Cognac

Looks: 29%
Sugar: 25%
Pastry: 74%
Filling: 59%
Value: 57%
Total: 54.7%

The Ugliest Pie award for the worst looks.
The Dusting Disaster award for the worst sugar.

See the judges’ scores

Judges	Looks	Sugar	Pastry	Filling	Value	Total
Andy						48.01%
Claire						62.05%
Dave						68.07%
Emma						69.77%
Euan						62.39%
Fraser						62.73%
Heather						39.72%
Jade						37.39%
Jeff						62.95%
Katie						44.89%
Katy						34.66%
Kirsty						21.70%
Lewis						72.73%
Lucy						38.01%
Michelle						36.59%
Mike						74.94%
Pete						63.92%
Phil						64.54%
Rob						74.20%
Total	29%	25%	74%	59%	57%	54.70%

See more of this pie

LidlDeluxe

Looks: 68%
Sugar: 62%
Pastry: 59%
Filling: 68%
Value: 68%
Total: 64.45%

See the judges’ scores

Judges	Looks	Sugar	Pastry	Filling	Value	Total
Andy						82.56%
Claire						49.38%
Dave						63.13%
Emma						71.82%
Euan						72.44%
Fraser						58.81%
Heather						57.95%
Jade						67.16%
Jeff						51.65%
Katie						74.72%
Katy						57.67%
Kirsty						81.76%
Lewis						47.04%
Lucy						82.33%
Michelle						64.09%
Mike						40.20%
Pete						67.73%
Phil						64.32%
Rob						69.77%
Total	68%	62%	59%	68%	68%	64.45%

See more of this pie

Looks: 82%
Sugar: 56%
Pastry: 86%
Filling: 88%
Value: 79%
Total: 80.42%

The Picture-Perfect Pie award for the best looks.
The Flakiest Favourite award for the best pastry.
The Merriest Mincemeat award for the best filling.

See the judges’ scores

Judges	Looks	Sugar	Pastry	Filling	Value	Total
Andy						86.08%
Claire						77.10%
Dave						75.40%
Emma						96.59%
Euan						90.91%
Fraser						91.76%
Heather						78.30%
Jade						81.53%
Jeff						76.59%
Katie						92.05%
Katy						87.50%
Kirsty						68.69%
Lewis						96.88%
Lucy						67.21%
Michelle						49.77%
Mike						86.86%
Pete						95.17%
Phil						41.02%
Rob						88.64%
Total	82%	56%	86%	88%	79%	80.42%

See more of this pie

AldiSpecially Selected

Looks: 60%
Sugar: 64%
Pastry: 68%
Filling: 67%
Value: 74%
Total: 64.16%

See the judges’ scores

Judges	Looks	Sugar	Pastry	Filling	Value	Total
Andy						67.10%
Claire						68.41%
Dave						61.14%
Emma						56.20%
Euan						45.11%
Fraser						57.73%
Heather						52.22%
Jade						71.08%
Jeff						61.70%
Katie						74.89%
Katy						75.57%
Kirsty						85.68%
Lewis						50.05%
Lucy						82.73%
Michelle						63.69%
Mike						34.72%
Pete						66.36%
Phil						78.58%
Rob						66.07%
Total	60%	64%	68%	67%	74%	64.16%

See more of this pie

Looks: 76%
Sugar: 67%
Pastry: 76%
Filling: 76%
Value: 89%
Total: 76.03%

The Value Victor award for the best value.

See the judges’ scores

Judges	Looks	Sugar	Pastry	Filling	Value	Total
Andy						71.99%
Claire						82.78%
Dave						94.89%
Emma						82.27%
Euan						83.98%
Fraser						90.28%
Heather						60.62%
Jade						76.30%
Jeff						69.09%
Katie						74.60%
Katy						38.92%
Kirsty						85.68%
Lewis						98.30%
Lucy						61.42%
Michelle						54.43%
Mike						71.63%
Pete						88.58%
Phil						69.09%
Rob						89.77%
Total	76%	67%	76%	76%	89%	76.03%

See more of this pie

Sainsbury’sTaste the Difference

Looks: 80%
Sugar: 66%
Pastry: 83%
Filling: 76%
Value: 57%
Total: 74.66%

See the judges’ scores

Judges	Looks	Sugar	Pastry	Filling	Value	Total
Andy						81.82%
Claire						82.90%
Dave						63.98%
Emma						61.14%
Euan						82.96%
Fraser						75.46%
Heather						65.28%
Jade						78.30%
Jeff						81.25%
Katie						71.03%
Katy						80.40%
Kirsty						70.57%
Lewis						74.32%
Lucy						95.97%
Michelle						57.27%
Mike						61.85%
Pete						75.46%
Phil						86.31%
Rob						72.31%
Total	80%	66%	83%	76%	57%	74.66%

See more of this pie

Sainsbury’s

Looks: 51%
Sugar: 49%
Pastry: 50%
Filling: 45%
Value: 61%
Total: 49.3%

See the judges’ scores

Judges	Looks	Sugar	Pastry	Filling	Value	Total
Andy						50.00%
Claire						27.38%
Dave						27.38%
Emma						64.60%
Euan						63.18%
Fraser						48.64%
Heather						50.05%
Jade						48.58%
Jeff						47.38%
Katie						46.02%
Katy						51.82%
Kirsty						49.77%
Lewis						47.44%
Lucy						41.99%
Michelle						51.08%
Mike						73.30%
Pete						47.78%
Phil						56.42%
Rob						43.80%
Total	51%	49%	50%	45%	61%	49.30%

See more of this pie

Iceland

Looks: 37%
Sugar: 58%
Pastry: 26%
Filling: 26%
Value: 42%
Total: 34.38%

The Crust Catastrophe award for the worst pastry.
The Filling Fail award for the worst filling.
The Festive Flop award for the worst overall score.

See the judges’ scores

Judges	Looks	Sugar	Pastry	Filling	Value	Total
Andy						54.77%
Claire						48.24%
Dave						34.89%
Emma						50.11%
Euan						33.35%
Fraser						17.67%
Heather						23.35%
Jade						38.30%
Jeff						43.35%
Katie						27.67%
Katy						27.38%
Kirsty						28.07%
Lewis						32.78%
Lucy						39.77%
Michelle						33.35%
Mike						39.37%
Pete						20.51%
Phil						37.05%
Rob						23.24%
Total	37%	58%	26%	26%	42%	34.38%

See more of this pie

2025Pie Charts

AsdaExceptional

Morrisons

AsdaOMV!

MorrisonsThe Best

WaitroseNo.1 Brown Butter with Cognac

LidlDeluxe

M&SClassic

AldiSpecially Selected

WaitroseAll Butter

Sainsbury’sTaste the Difference

Sainsbury’s

Iceland

The year in graphs