2024 Talking Mince Pie Charts

Looks: 81%
Sugar: 64%
Pastry: 78%
Filling: 82%
Value: 76%
Total: 76.99%

See the judges’ scores

Judges	Looks	Sugar	Pastry	Filling	Value	Total
Andy						87.44%
Dave						68.35%
Emma						63.41%
Euan						86.31%
Fraser						79.49%
Heather						79.15%
Jade						87.44%
Jeff						68.64%
Katie						86.25%
Katy						65.23%
Kirsty						88.52%
Lewis						79.49%
Lucy						88.24%
Michelle						41.02%
Mike						83.41%
Pete						74.32%
Rob						77.50%
Stuart						81.65%
Total	81%	64%	78%	82%	76%	76.99%

See more of this pie

AldiSpecially Selected Frangipane

Looks: 49%
Sugar: 28%
Pastry: 49%
Filling: 46%
Value: 57%
Total: 45.39%

The Dusting Disaster award for the worst sugar.
The Filling Fail award for the worst filling.

See the judges’ scores

Judges	Looks	Sugar	Pastry	Filling	Value	Total
Andy						61.48%
Dave						67.50%
Emma						54.32%
Euan						40.00%
Fraser						57.73%
Heather						63.92%
Jade						44.66%
Jeff						41.98%
Katie						25.79%
Katy						69.77%
Kirsty						57.16%
Lewis						14.03%
Lucy						17.67%
Michelle						65.68%
Mike						41.81%
Pete						40.57%
Rob						17.10%
Stuart						35.80%
Total	49%	28%	49%	46%	57%	45.39%

See more of this pie

M&SThe Collection

Looks: 64%
Sugar: 63%
Pastry: 72%
Filling: 83%
Value: 52%
Total: 71.21%

The Merriest Mincemeat award for the best filling.

See the judges’ scores

Judges	Looks	Sugar	Pastry	Filling	Value	Total
Andy						86.88%
Dave						57.11%
Emma						81.14%
Euan						58.13%
Fraser						67.39%
Heather						86.88%
Jade						68.30%
Jeff						71.20%
Katie						74.09%
Katy						26.93%
Kirsty						74.43%
Lewis						55.80%
Lucy						89.21%
Michelle						72.67%
Mike						87.39%
Pete						70.80%
Rob						76.37%
Stuart						77.16%
Total	64%	63%	72%	83%	52%	71.21%

See more of this pie

Mr. KiplingDeep Filled

Looks: 63%
Sugar: 41%
Pastry: 48%
Filling: 62%
Value: 63%
Total: 54.29%

See the judges’ scores

Judges	Looks	Sugar	Pastry	Filling	Value	Total
Andy						61.14%
Dave						36.25%
Emma						54.20%
Euan						54.54%
Fraser						37.04%
Heather						49.09%
Jade						56.20%
Jeff						61.08%
Katie						54.15%
Katy						72.89%
Kirsty						72.05%
Lewis						49.94%
Lucy						57.21%
Michelle						55.40%
Mike						41.87%
Pete						47.38%
Rob						50.23%
Stuart						66.62%
Total	63%	41%	48%	62%	63%	54.29%

See more of this pie

WaitroseNo.1 Brown Butter with Cognac

Looks: 31%
Sugar: 52%
Pastry: 74%
Filling: 64%
Value: 43%
Total: 59.67%

The Ugliest Pie award for the worst looks.

See the judges’ scores

Judges	Looks	Sugar	Pastry	Filling	Value	Total
Andy						57.28%
Dave						51.71%
Emma						63.53%
Euan						50.97%
Fraser						61.25%
Heather						19.15%
Jade						64.66%
Jeff						49.83%
Katie						70.74%
Katy						57.39%
Kirsty						57.27%
Lewis						70.63%
Lucy						64.60%
Michelle						72.62%
Mike						61.14%
Pete						67.22%
Rob						64.89%
Stuart						69.21%
Total	31%	52%	74%	64%	43%	59.67%

See more of this pie

LidlDeluxe

Looks: 76%
Sugar: 58%
Pastry: 73%
Filling: 74%
Value: 84%
Total: 72.26%

See the judges’ scores

Judges	Looks	Sugar	Pastry	Filling	Value	Total
Andy						76.59%
Dave						46.14%
Emma						82.61%
Euan						82.33%
Fraser						76.02%
Heather						66.53%
Jade						73.46%
Jeff						76.87%
Katie						46.82%
Katy						85.17%
Kirsty						70.05%
Lewis						59.32%
Lucy						84.32%
Michelle						60.85%
Mike						70.62%
Pete						77.73%
Rob						74.60%
Stuart						90.62%
Total	76%	58%	73%	74%	84%	72.26%

See more of this pie

Looks: 71%
Sugar: 66%
Pastry: 81%
Filling: 81%
Value: 88%
Total: 78.12%

The Flakiest Favourite award for the best pastry.
The Value Victor award for the best value.

See the judges’ scores

Judges	Looks	Sugar	Pastry	Filling	Value	Total
Andy						85.74%
Dave						74.32%
Emma						91.48%
Euan						69.43%
Fraser						76.25%
Heather						73.18%
Jade						82.27%
Jeff						82.27%
Katie						98.30%
Katy						73.80%
Kirsty						69.31%
Lewis						76.53%
Lucy						82.22%
Michelle						81.14%
Mike						80.85%
Pete						80.00%
Rob						65.68%
Stuart						63.46%
Total	71%	66%	81%	81%	88%	78.12%

See more of this pie

AldiSpecially Selected

Looks: 74%
Sugar: 64%
Pastry: 59%
Filling: 70%
Value: 71%
Total: 66.05%

See the judges’ scores

Judges	Looks	Sugar	Pastry	Filling	Value	Total
Andy						80.85%
Dave						73.98%
Emma						59.71%
Euan						71.02%
Fraser						74.54%
Heather						79.66%
Jade						68.18%
Jeff						67.73%
Katie						57.04%
Katy						61.73%
Kirsty						59.60%
Lewis						68.01%
Lucy						63.92%
Michelle						46.65%
Mike						57.33%
Pete						73.13%
Rob						55.91%
Stuart						69.89%
Total	74%	64%	59%	70%	71%	66.05%

See more of this pie

Looks: 84%
Sugar: 72%
Pastry: 75%
Filling: 82%
Value: 76%
Total: 77.78%

The Picture-Perfect Pie award for the best looks.
The Sweet Spot award for the best sugar.

See the judges’ scores

Judges	Looks	Sugar	Pastry	Filling	Value	Total
Andy						79.66%
Dave						72.62%
Emma						71.19%
Euan						71.42%
Fraser						90.00%
Heather						74.26%
Jade						65.63%
Jeff						80.06%
Katie						77.56%
Katy						53.30%
Kirsty						76.87%
Lewis						92.56%
Lucy						72.84%
Michelle						75.91%
Mike						94.03%
Pete						92.56%
Rob						76.76%
Stuart						82.84%
Total	84%	72%	75%	82%	76%	77.78%

See more of this pie

MorrisonsThe Best

Looks: 48%
Sugar: 48%
Pastry: 40%
Filling: 48%
Value: 33%
Total: 44.12%

The Wallet Waster award for the worst value.
The Festive Flop award for the worst overall score.

See the judges’ scores

Judges	Looks	Sugar	Pastry	Filling	Value	Total
Andy						64.77%
Dave						51.53%
Emma						51.76%
Euan						40.23%
Fraser						42.56%
Heather						43.41%
Jade						41.99%
Jeff						38.52%
Katie						30.23%
Katy						53.07%
Kirsty						55.34%
Lewis						34.89%
Lucy						38.47%
Michelle						31.42%
Mike						27.67%
Pete						50.86%
Rob						49.15%
Stuart						48.30%
Total	48%	48%	40%	48%	33%	44.12%

See more of this pie

Sainsbury’sTaste the Difference

Looks: 72%
Sugar: 59%
Pastry: 77%
Filling: 69%
Value: 61%
Total: 69.09%

See the judges’ scores

Judges	Looks	Sugar	Pastry	Filling	Value	Total
Andy						78.01%
Dave						68.86%
Emma						85.80%
Euan						81.82%
Fraser						72.90%
Heather						57.67%
Jade						80.68%
Jeff						68.92%
Katie						64.77%
Katy						45.40%
Kirsty						74.32%
Lewis						42.33%
Lucy						65.23%
Michelle						59.21%
Mike						88.01%
Pete						55.40%
Rob						84.03%
Stuart						70.34%
Total	72%	59%	77%	69%	61%	69.09%

See more of this pie

LidlFavorina

Looks: 61%
Sugar: 51%
Pastry: 25%
Filling: 50%
Value: 54%
Total: 44.4%

The Crust Catastrophe award for the worst pastry.

See the judges’ scores

Judges	Looks	Sugar	Pastry	Filling	Value	Total
Andy						47.33%
Dave						48.92%
Emma						33.07%
Euan						39.88%
Fraser						35.91%
Heather						43.35%
Jade						37.61%
Jeff						57.61%
Katie						56.13%
Katy						55.23%
Kirsty						61.02%
Lewis						42.73%
Lucy						40.96%
Michelle						48.24%
Mike						34.83%
Pete						32.50%
Rob						32.50%
Stuart						51.31%
Total	61%	51%	25%	50%	54%	44.40%

See more of this pie

2024Talking Mince
Pie Charts

TescoFinest

AldiSpecially Selected Frangipane

M&SThe Collection

Mr. KiplingDeep Filled

WaitroseNo.1 Brown Butter with Cognac

LidlDeluxe

WaitroseAll Butter

AldiSpecially Selected

M&SClassic

MorrisonsThe Best

Sainsbury’sTaste the Difference

LidlFavorina

The year in graphs