TescoFinest

Looks
81%
Sugar
64%
Pastry
78%
Filling
82%
Value
76%
Total
76.99%
See the judges’ scores
JudgesLooksSugarPastryFillingValueTotal
Andy87.44%
Dave68.35%
Emma63.41%
Euan86.31%
Fraser79.49%
Heather79.15%
Jade87.44%
Jeff68.64%
Katie86.25%
Katy65.23%
Kirsty88.52%
Lewis79.49%
Lucy88.24%
Michelle41.02%
Mike83.41%
Pete74.32%
Rob77.50%
Stuart81.65%
Total81%64%78%82%76%76.99%
See more of this pie

AldiSpecially Selected Frangipane

Looks
49%
Sugar
28%
Pastry
49%
Filling
46%
Value
57%
Total
45.39%
See the judges’ scores
JudgesLooksSugarPastryFillingValueTotal
Andy61.48%
Dave67.50%
Emma54.32%
Euan40.00%
Fraser57.73%
Heather63.92%
Jade44.66%
Jeff41.98%
Katie25.79%
Katy69.77%
Kirsty57.16%
Lewis14.03%
Lucy17.67%
Michelle65.68%
Mike41.81%
Pete40.57%
Rob17.10%
Stuart35.80%
Total49%28%49%46%57%45.39%
See more of this pie

M&SThe Collection

Looks
64%
Sugar
63%
Pastry
72%
Filling
83%
Value
52%
Total
71.21%
See the judges’ scores
JudgesLooksSugarPastryFillingValueTotal
Andy86.88%
Dave57.11%
Emma81.14%
Euan58.13%
Fraser67.39%
Heather86.88%
Jade68.30%
Jeff71.20%
Katie74.09%
Katy26.93%
Kirsty74.43%
Lewis55.80%
Lucy89.21%
Michelle72.67%
Mike87.39%
Pete70.80%
Rob76.37%
Stuart77.16%
Total64%63%72%83%52%71.21%
See more of this pie

Mr. KiplingDeep Filled

Looks
63%
Sugar
41%
Pastry
48%
Filling
62%
Value
63%
Total
54.29%
See the judges’ scores
JudgesLooksSugarPastryFillingValueTotal
Andy61.14%
Dave36.25%
Emma54.20%
Euan54.54%
Fraser37.04%
Heather49.09%
Jade56.20%
Jeff61.08%
Katie54.15%
Katy72.89%
Kirsty72.05%
Lewis49.94%
Lucy57.21%
Michelle55.40%
Mike41.87%
Pete47.38%
Rob50.23%
Stuart66.62%
Total63%41%48%62%63%54.29%
See more of this pie

WaitroseNo. 1 Brown Butter with Cognac

Looks
31%
Sugar
52%
Pastry
74%
Filling
64%
Value
43%
Total
59.67%
See the judges’ scores
JudgesLooksSugarPastryFillingValueTotal
Andy57.28%
Dave51.71%
Emma63.53%
Euan50.97%
Fraser61.25%
Heather19.15%
Jade64.66%
Jeff49.83%
Katie70.74%
Katy57.39%
Kirsty57.27%
Lewis70.63%
Lucy64.60%
Michelle72.62%
Mike61.14%
Pete67.22%
Rob64.89%
Stuart69.21%
Total31%52%74%64%43%59.67%
See more of this pie

LidlDeluxe

Looks
76%
Sugar
58%
Pastry
73%
Filling
74%
Value
84%
Total
72.26%
See the judges’ scores
JudgesLooksSugarPastryFillingValueTotal
Andy76.59%
Dave46.14%
Emma82.61%
Euan82.33%
Fraser76.02%
Heather66.53%
Jade73.46%
Jeff76.87%
Katie46.82%
Katy85.17%
Kirsty70.05%
Lewis59.32%
Lucy84.32%
Michelle60.85%
Mike70.62%
Pete77.73%
Rob74.60%
Stuart90.62%
Total76%58%73%74%84%72.26%
See more of this pie

Waitrose

Looks
71%
Sugar
66%
Pastry
81%
Filling
81%
Value
88%
Total
78.12%
See the judges’ scores
JudgesLooksSugarPastryFillingValueTotal
Andy85.74%
Dave74.32%
Emma91.48%
Euan69.43%
Fraser76.25%
Heather73.18%
Jade82.27%
Jeff82.27%
Katie98.30%
Katy73.80%
Kirsty69.31%
Lewis76.53%
Lucy82.22%
Michelle81.14%
Mike80.85%
Pete80.00%
Rob65.68%
Stuart63.46%
Total71%66%81%81%88%78.12%
See more of this pie

AldiSpecially Selected

Looks
74%
Sugar
64%
Pastry
59%
Filling
70%
Value
71%
Total
66.05%
See the judges’ scores
JudgesLooksSugarPastryFillingValueTotal
Andy80.85%
Dave73.98%
Emma59.71%
Euan71.02%
Fraser74.54%
Heather79.66%
Jade68.18%
Jeff67.73%
Katie57.04%
Katy61.73%
Kirsty59.60%
Lewis68.01%
Lucy63.92%
Michelle46.65%
Mike57.33%
Pete73.13%
Rob55.91%
Stuart69.89%
Total74%64%59%70%71%66.05%
See more of this pie

M&SClassic

Looks
84%
Sugar
72%
Pastry
75%
Filling
82%
Value
76%
Total
77.78%
See the judges’ scores
JudgesLooksSugarPastryFillingValueTotal
Andy79.66%
Dave72.62%
Emma71.19%
Euan71.42%
Fraser90.00%
Heather74.26%
Jade65.63%
Jeff80.06%
Katie77.56%
Katy53.30%
Kirsty76.87%
Lewis92.56%
Lucy72.84%
Michelle75.91%
Mike94.03%
Pete92.56%
Rob76.76%
Stuart82.84%
Total84%72%75%82%76%77.78%
See more of this pie

MorrisonsThe Best

Looks
48%
Sugar
48%
Pastry
40%
Filling
48%
Value
33%
Total
44.12%
See the judges’ scores
JudgesLooksSugarPastryFillingValueTotal
Andy64.77%
Dave51.53%
Emma51.76%
Euan40.23%
Fraser42.56%
Heather43.41%
Jade41.99%
Jeff38.52%
Katie30.23%
Katy53.07%
Kirsty55.34%
Lewis34.89%
Lucy38.47%
Michelle31.42%
Mike27.67%
Pete50.86%
Rob49.15%
Stuart48.30%
Total48%48%40%48%33%44.12%
See more of this pie

Sainsbury’sTaste the Difference

Looks
72%
Sugar
59%
Pastry
77%
Filling
69%
Value
61%
Total
69.09%
See the judges’ scores
JudgesLooksSugarPastryFillingValueTotal
Andy78.01%
Dave68.86%
Emma85.80%
Euan81.82%
Fraser72.90%
Heather57.67%
Jade80.68%
Jeff68.92%
Katie64.77%
Katy45.40%
Kirsty74.32%
Lewis42.33%
Lucy65.23%
Michelle59.21%
Mike88.01%
Pete55.40%
Rob84.03%
Stuart70.34%
Total72%59%77%69%61%69.09%
See more of this pie

LidlFavorina

Looks
61%
Sugar
51%
Pastry
25%
Filling
50%
Value
54%
Total
44.4%
See the judges’ scores
JudgesLooksSugarPastryFillingValueTotal
Andy47.33%
Dave48.92%
Emma33.07%
Euan39.88%
Fraser35.91%
Heather43.35%
Jade37.61%
Jeff57.61%
Katie56.13%
Katy55.23%
Kirsty61.02%
Lewis42.73%
Lucy40.96%
Michelle48.24%
Mike34.83%
Pete32.50%
Rob32.50%
Stuart51.31%
Total61%51%25%50%54%44.40%
See more of this pie

The year in graphs

Graph Data:

Tesco: Finest
Total76.99%
Price£3.00
Looks81.11%
Sugar63.89%
Pastry78.33%
Filling81.67%
Value76.11%
Aldi: Specially Selected Frangipane
Total45.39%
Price£2.59
Looks48.89%
Sugar27.78%
Pastry49.44%
Filling46.11%
Value56.67%
M&S: The Collection
Total71.21%
Price£4.00
Looks64.44%
Sugar62.78%
Pastry72.22%
Filling82.78%
Value51.67%
Mr. Kipling: Deep Filled
Total54.29%
Price£2.50
Looks63.33%
Sugar40.56%
Pastry47.5%
Filling61.67%
Value63.33%
Waitrose: No. 1 Brown Butter with Cognac
Total59.67%
Price£4.00
Looks31.11%
Sugar52.22%
Pastry73.89%
Filling63.89%
Value43.33%
Lidl: Deluxe
Total72.26%
Price£2.29
Looks75.56%
Sugar57.78%
Pastry73.33%
Filling73.89%
Value83.89%
Waitrose
Total78.12%
Price£2.20
Looks70.56%
Sugar66.11%
Pastry80.56%
Filling80.56%
Value88.33%
Aldi: Specially Selected
Total66.05%
Price£2.29
Looks73.89%
Sugar64.44%
Pastry58.56%
Filling69.67%
Value70.83%
M&S: Classic
Total77.78%
Price£2.70
Looks84.44%
Sugar72.22%
Pastry75%
Filling82%
Value75.56%
Morrisons: The Best
Total44.12%
Price£2.75
Looks48.33%
Sugar47.78%
Pastry40%
Filling48.33%
Value33.33%
Sainsbury’s: Taste the Difference
Total69.09%
Price£3.00
Looks71.67%
Sugar58.61%
Pastry77.22%
Filling69.44%
Value61.11%
Lidl: Favorina
Total44.4%
Price£1.25
Looks61.11%
Sugar51.11%
Pastry25%
Filling50%
Value54.44%