Andy

Looks
66%
Sugar
63%
Pastry
69%
Filling
81%
Value
74%
Total
72.29%

Best & worst

Favourite pie
M&S: Classic
Least favourite pie
Mr. Kipling: Deep Filled

Awards

  • The Pretty Pie Patron award for the most positive looks scoring.
  • The Crust Connoisseur award for the most positive pastry scoring.
  • The Filling Fanatic award for the most positive filling scoring.
  • The Budget Buff award for the most positive value scoring.
  • The Mince Pie Maestro award for the most positive total scoring.

Dave

Looks
66%
Sugar
53%
Pastry
60%
Filling
67%
Value
63%
Total
62.06%

Best & worst

Favourite pie
Morrisons: The Best
Least favourite pie
Mr. Kipling: Deep Filled

Euan

Looks
64%
Sugar
54%
Pastry
65%
Filling
74%
Value
67%
Total
66.49%

Best & worst

Favourite pie
M&S: Classic
Least favourite pie
Mr. Kipling: Deep Filled

Fraser

Looks
63%
Sugar
49%
Pastry
64%
Filling
70%
Value
67%
Total
63.74%

Best & worst

Favourite pie
Tesco: Finest
Least favourite pie
Mr. Kipling: Deep Filled

Heather

Looks
65%
Sugar
58%
Pastry
66%
Filling
76%
Value
70%
Total
68.22%

Best & worst

Favourite pie
Co-op: Irresistible
Least favourite pie
Mr. Kipling: Deep Filled

Jade

Looks
63%
Sugar
62%
Pastry
65%
Filling
67%
Value
64%
Total
64.98%

Best & worst

Favourite pie
Tesco: Finest
Least favourite pie
Mr. Kipling: Deep Filled

Katie

Looks
64%
Sugar
64%
Pastry
53%
Filling
66%
Value
55%
Total
60.55%

Best & worst

Favourite pie
Tesco: Finest
Least favourite pie
Mr. Kipling: Deep Filled

Awards

  • The Sweet Tooth award for the most positive sugar scoring.
  • The Crusty Critic award for the most critical pastry scoring.
  • The Penny Pincher award for the most critical value scoring.

Katy

Looks
48%
Sugar
48%
Pastry
67%
Filling
59%
Value
57%
Total
58.46%

Best & worst

Favourite pie
Morrisons: The Best
Least favourite pie
Mr. Kipling: Deep Filled

Awards

  • The Eyesore Evaluator award for the most critical looks scoring.
  • The Stuffing Scrooge award for the most critical filling scoring.
  • The Grinch of the Pies award for the most critical total scoring.

Kirsty

Looks
62%
Sugar
58%
Pastry
64%
Filling
64%
Value
67%
Total
63.1%

Best & worst

Favourite pie
Morrisons: The Best
Least favourite pie
Mr. Kipling: Deep Filled

Lewis

Looks
57%
Sugar
43%
Pastry
59%
Filling
67%
Value
57%
Total
58.67%

Best & worst

Favourite pie
M&S: Classic
Least favourite pie
Mr. Kipling: Deep Filled

Awards

  • The Sugar Skeptic award for the most critical sugar scoring.

Pete

Looks
57%
Sugar
53%
Pastry
63%
Filling
67%
Value
55%
Total
60.87%

Best & worst

Favourite pie
M&S: Classic
Least favourite pie
Mr. Kipling: Deep Filled

Rob

Looks
57%
Sugar
54%
Pastry
60%
Filling
69%
Value
62%
Total
62.04%

Best & worst

Favourite pie
M&S: Classic
Least favourite pie
Mr. Kipling: Deep Filled