Iceland

Looks
35%
Sugar
38%
Pastry
79%
Filling
64%
Value
87%
Total
64.18%
See the judges’ scores
JudgesLooksSugarPastryFillingValueTotal
Andy66.99%
Dave61.93%
Euan60.00%
Fraser59.83%
Heather62.95%
Jade62.10%
Katie70.68%
Katy66.42%
Kirsty65.28%
Lewis69.77%
Pete62.95%
Rob61.25%
Total35%38%79%64%87%64.18%
See more of this pie

Tesco FinestSpiced Rum

Looks
60%
Sugar
77%
Pastry
52%
Filling
38%
Value
45%
Total
51.05%
See the judges’ scores
JudgesLooksSugarPastryFillingValueTotal
Andy67.67%
Dave70.34%
Euan48.01%
Fraser41.99%
Heather66.82%
Jade39.77%
Katie39.09%
Katy60.00%
Kirsty41.99%
Lewis30.06%
Pete58.86%
Rob48.01%
Total60%77%52%38%45%51.05%
See more of this pie

LidlDeluxe

Looks
76%
Sugar
38%
Pastry
68%
Filling
71%
Value
73%
Total
65.18%
See the judges’ scores
JudgesLooksSugarPastryFillingValueTotal
Andy64.54%
Dave47.44%
Euan76.08%
Fraser62.33%
Heather66.87%
Jade66.25%
Katie45.06%
Katy56.13%
Kirsty82.27%
Lewis81.19%
Pete69.77%
Rob64.26%
Total76%38%68%71%73%65.18%
See more of this pie

TescoFinest

Looks
71%
Sugar
72%
Pastry
73%
Filling
83%
Value
77%
Total
76.38%
See the judges’ scores
JudgesLooksSugarPastryFillingValueTotal
Andy83.92%
Dave75.40%
Euan80.00%
Fraser80.51%
Heather75.91%
Jade80.51%
Katie86.25%
Katy58.30%
Kirsty74.89%
Lewis64.60%
Pete75.74%
Rob80.57%
Total71%72%73%83%77%76.38%
See more of this pie

Co-opIrresistible

Looks
52%
Sugar
71%
Pastry
53%
Filling
73%
Value
51%
Total
61.09%
See the judges’ scores
JudgesLooksSugarPastryFillingValueTotal
Andy77.61%
Dave58.24%
Euan61.88%
Fraser74.49%
Heather82.22%
Jade66.82%
Katie58.30%
Katy69.21%
Kirsty42.84%
Lewis61.59%
Pete64.49%
Rob31.93%
Total52%71%53%73%51%61.09%
See more of this pie

AsdaExtra Special

Looks
68%
Sugar
53%
Pastry
70%
Filling
72%
Value
70%
Total
67.51%
See the judges’ scores
JudgesLooksSugarPastryFillingValueTotal
Andy80.85%
Dave68.30%
Euan72.05%
Fraser55.74%
Heather72.67%
Jade68.47%
Katie71.65%
Katy30.91%
Kirsty76.59%
Lewis74.03%
Pete64.03%
Rob74.89%
Total68%53%70%72%70%67.51%
See more of this pie

M&SThe Collection

Looks
58%
Sugar
45%
Pastry
65%
Filling
89%
Value
35%
Total
65.78%
See the judges’ scores
JudgesLooksSugarPastryFillingValueTotal
Andy78.92%
Dave60.29%
Euan67.45%
Fraser64.32%
Heather76.88%
Jade75.23%
Katie56.26%
Katy70.92%
Kirsty61.14%
Lewis44.55%
Pete64.32%
Rob69.15%
Total57%45%65%89%35%65.78%
See more of this pie

MorrisonsThe Best

Looks
68%
Sugar
60%
Pastry
69%
Filling
86%
Value
79%
Total
74.28%
See the judges’ scores
JudgesLooksSugarPastryFillingValueTotal
Andy65.06%
Dave77.44%
Euan60.45%
Fraser63.35%
Heather66.42%
Jade73.12%
Katie80.68%
Katy79.83%
Kirsty94.89%
Lewis75.91%
Pete68.52%
Rob85.68%
Total68%60%69%86%79%74.28%
See more of this pie

M&SClassic

Looks
77%
Sugar
74%
Pastry
86%
Filling
78%
Value
83%
Total
79.84%
See the judges’ scores
JudgesLooksSugarPastryFillingValueTotal
Andy95.40%
Dave66.59%
Euan92.84%
Fraser79.49%
Heather81.19%
Jade78.30%
Katie62.27%
Katy70.45%
Kirsty61.82%
Lewis86.36%
Pete90.91%
Rob92.50%
Total77%74%86%78%83%79.84%
See more of this pie

Mr. KiplingDeep Filled

Looks
34%
Sugar
10%
Pastry
21%
Filling
44%
Value
28%
Total
28.93%
See the judges’ scores
JudgesLooksSugarPastryFillingValueTotal
Andy38.30%
Dave32.56%
Euan41.36%
Fraser38.30%
Heather27.95%
Jade25.11%
Katie24.77%
Katy19.32%
Kirsty30.51%
Lewis29.66%
Pete15.91%
Rob23.41%
Total34%10%21%44%28%28.93%
See more of this pie

Morrisons

Looks
58%
Sugar
49%
Pastry
57%
Filling
58%
Value
67%
Total
57.16%
See the judges’ scores
JudgesLooksSugarPastryFillingValueTotal
Andy75.68%
Dave52.27%
Euan63.46%
Fraser66.87%
Heather71.48%
Jade70.91%
Katie51.65%
Katy54.89%
Kirsty50.79%
Lewis40.57%
Pete32.62%
Rob54.77%
Total57%49%57%58%67%57.16%
See more of this pie

Sainsbury’sTaste the Difference

Looks
75%
Sugar
69%
Pastry
64%
Filling
73%
Value
63%
Total
68.69%
See the judges’ scores
JudgesLooksSugarPastryFillingValueTotal
Andy72.56%
Dave73.92%
Euan74.32%
Fraser77.67%
Heather67.33%
Jade73.13%
Katie80.00%
Katy65.11%
Kirsty74.20%
Lewis45.74%
Pete62.27%
Rob58.01%
Total75%69%64%73%63%68.69%
See more of this pie

The year in graphs

Graph Data:

Iceland
Total64.18%
Price£1.20
Looks35%
Sugar38.33%
Pastry79.17%
Filling64.17%
Value86.67%
Tesco Finest: Spiced Rum
Total51.05%
Price£2.25
Looks60%
Sugar76.67%
Pastry51.67%
Filling37.5%
Value45%
Lidl: Deluxe
Total65.18%
Price£1.75
Looks75.83%
Sugar38.33%
Pastry68.33%
Filling70.83%
Value72.5%
Tesco: Finest
Total76.38%
Price£2.25
Looks70.83%
Sugar71.67%
Pastry72.5%
Filling83.33%
Value76.67%
Co-op: Irresistible
Total61.09%
Price£2.25
Looks51.67%
Sugar70.83%
Pastry52.5%
Filling73.33%
Value50.83%
Asda: Extra Special
Total67.51%
Price£2.25
Looks67.5%
Sugar53.33%
Pastry70%
Filling71.67%
Value70%
M&S: The Collection
Total65.78%
Price£3.00
Looks57.5%
Sugar45%
Pastry65%
Filling89.17%
Value35%
Morrisons: The Best
Total74.28%
Price£2.25
Looks67.5%
Sugar60%
Pastry69.17%
Filling85.83%
Value79.17%
M&S: Classic
Total79.84%
Price£2.20
Looks76.67%
Sugar74.17%
Pastry85.83%
Filling77.5%
Value82.5%
Mr. Kipling: Deep Filled
Total28.93%
Price£1.75
Looks34.17%
Sugar10%
Pastry20.83%
Filling44.17%
Value28.33%
Morrisons
Total57.16%
Price£1.25
Looks57.5%
Sugar49.17%
Pastry56.67%
Filling58.33%
Value66.67%
Sainsbury’s: Taste the Difference
Total68.69%
Price£2.25
Looks75%
Sugar69.17%
Pastry64.17%
Filling72.5%
Value63.33%