AldiSpecially Selected

Looks
55%
Sugar
29%
Pastry
58%
Filling
55%
Value
62%
Total
52.23%
See the judges’ scores
JudgesLooksSugarPastryFillingValueTotal
Andy68.64%
Dave46.53%
Fraser47.73%
Heather55.74%
Jade60.62%
Katy53.86%
Kirsty52.16%
Lewis48.81%
Pete49.37%
Rob38.86%
Total55%29%58%55%62%52.23%
See more of this pie

LidlDeluxe

Looks
73%
Sugar
48%
Pastry
73%
Filling
79%
Value
80%
Total
71.58%
See the judges’ scores
JudgesLooksSugarPastryFillingValueTotal
Andy71.19%
Dave65.91%
Fraser62.33%
Heather74.89%
Jade80.62%
Katy84.66%
Kirsty64.15%
Lewis72.33%
Pete75.74%
Rob63.98%
Total73%48%73%79%80%71.58%
See more of this pie

Asda

Looks
66%
Sugar
55%
Pastry
64%
Filling
59%
Value
82%
Total
62.98%
See the judges’ scores
JudgesLooksSugarPastryFillingValueTotal
Andy86.02%
Dave73.46%
Fraser61.76%
Heather78.01%
Jade71.70%
Katy68.07%
Kirsty62.95%
Lewis37.38%
Pete35.91%
Rob54.48%
Total66%55%64%59%82%62.98%
See more of this pie

TescoPlant Chef

Looks
30%
Sugar
44%
Pastry
51%
Filling
51%
Value
45%
Total
47.34%
See the judges’ scores
JudgesLooksSugarPastryFillingValueTotal
Andy48.35%
Dave46.25%
Fraser31.36%
Heather44.09%
Jade41.19%
Katy40.68%
Kirsty38.30%
Lewis69.72%
Pete61.42%
Rob51.99%
Total30%44%51%51%45%47.34%
See more of this pie

TescoFinest

Looks
89%
Sugar
72%
Pastry
83%
Filling
76%
Value
76%
Total
79.56%
See the judges’ scores
JudgesLooksSugarPastryFillingValueTotal
Andy68.52%
Dave77.10%
Fraser89.49%
Heather61.70%
Jade78.47%
Katy73.87%
Kirsty86.36%
Lewis83.24%
Pete77.44%
Rob88.35%
Total89%72%83%76%76%79.56%
See more of this pie

Co-opIrresistible

Looks
31%
Sugar
39%
Pastry
61%
Filling
58%
Value
39%
Total
51.17%
See the judges’ scores
JudgesLooksSugarPastryFillingValueTotal
Andy33.13%
Dave65.97%
Fraser48.35%
Heather38.30%
Jade62.39%
Katy43.53%
Kirsty52.62%
Lewis64.21%
Pete52.33%
Rob50.91%
Total31%39%61%58%39%51.17%
See more of this pie

M&SClassic

Looks
77%
Sugar
84%
Pastry
85%
Filling
86%
Value
89%
Total
84.94%
See the judges’ scores
JudgesLooksSugarPastryFillingValueTotal
Andy89.09%
Dave75.74%
Fraser73.69%
Heather83.18%
Jade74.26%
Katy84.66%
Kirsty94.89%
Lewis94.26%
Pete88.30%
Rob91.36%
Total77%84%85%86%89%84.94%
See more of this pie

AsdaLuxury Sloe Gin

Looks
60%
Sugar
52%
Pastry
69%
Filling
55%
Value
58%
Total
59.31%
See the judges’ scores
JudgesLooksSugarPastryFillingValueTotal
Andy73.41%
Dave60.62%
Fraser52.90%
Heather85.46%
Jade46.31%
Katy76.65%
Kirsty44.66%
Lewis53.24%
Pete53.24%
Rob46.65%
Total60%52%69%55%58%59.31%
See more of this pie

Morrisons

Looks
50%
Sugar
46%
Pastry
70%
Filling
71%
Value
81%
Total
65.79%
See the judges’ scores
JudgesLooksSugarPastryFillingValueTotal
Andy70.28%
Dave63.75%
Fraser63.46%
Heather67.38%
Jade66.87%
Katy82.10%
Kirsty62.27%
Lewis63.47%
Pete60.05%
Rob58.29%
Total50%46%70%71%81%65.79%
See more of this pie

Sainsbury’s

Looks
44%
Sugar
42%
Pastry
18%
Filling
22%
Value
26%
Total
26.58%
See the judges’ scores
JudgesLooksSugarPastryFillingValueTotal
Andy26.82%
Dave39.09%
Fraser28.24%
Heather17.10%
Jade35.34%
Katy0.00%
Kirsty23.41%
Lewis36.48%
Pete30.23%
Rob29.09%
Total44%42%18%22%26%26.58%
See more of this pie

Iceland

Looks
44%
Sugar
64%
Pastry
62%
Filling
64%
Value
70%
Total
62.4%
See the judges’ scores
JudgesLooksSugarPastryFillingValueTotal
Andy68.58%
Dave71.48%
Fraser63.18%
Heather66.02%
Jade63.35%
Katy48.81%
Kirsty65.68%
Lewis59.15%
Pete61.99%
Rob55.74%
Total44%64%62%64%70%62.40%
See more of this pie

Sainsbury’sTaste the Difference

Looks
76%
Sugar
53%
Pastry
77%
Filling
69%
Value
54%
Total
67.48%
See the judges’ scores
JudgesLooksSugarPastryFillingValueTotal
Andy70.57%
Dave73.98%
Fraser73.47%
Heather62.27%
Jade78.41%
Katy64.21%
Kirsty47.38%
Lewis67.45%
Pete68.35%
Rob68.75%
Total76%53%77%69%54%67.48%
See more of this pie

The year in graphs

Graph Data:

Aldi: Specially Selected
Total52.23%
Price£1.49
Looks55%
Sugar29%
Pastry58%
Filling55%
Value62%
Lidl: Deluxe
Total71.58%
Price£1.49
Looks73%
Sugar48%
Pastry73%
Filling79%
Value80%
Asda
Total62.98%
Price£0.87
Looks66%
Sugar55%
Pastry64%
Filling59%
Value82%
Tesco: Plant Chef
Total47.34%
Price£1.25
Looks30%
Sugar44%
Pastry51%
Filling51%
Value45%
Tesco: Finest
Total79.56%
Price£2.00
Looks89%
Sugar72%
Pastry83%
Filling76%
Value76%
Co-op: Irresistible
Total51.17%
Price£2.00
Looks31%
Sugar39%
Pastry61%
Filling58%
Value39%
M&S: Classic
Total84.94%
Price£1.80
Looks77%
Sugar84%
Pastry85%
Filling86%
Value89%
Asda: Luxury Sloe Gin
Total59.31%
Price£2.00
Looks60%
Sugar52%
Pastry69%
Filling55%
Value58%
Morrisons
Total65.79%
Price£0.99
Looks50%
Sugar46%
Pastry70%
Filling71%
Value81%
Sainsbury’s
Total26.58%
Price£1.20
Looks44%
Sugar42%
Pastry18%
Filling22%
Value26%
Iceland
Total62.4%
Price£1.00
Looks44%
Sugar64%
Pastry62%
Filling64%
Value70%
Sainsbury’s: Taste the Difference
Total67.48%
Price£2.20
Looks76%
Sugar53%
Pastry77%
Filling69%
Value54%