2021 Pelosi Mince Pie Inquiry

AldiSpecially Selected

Looks: 55%
Sugar: 29%
Pastry: 58%
Filling: 55%
Value: 62%
Total: 52.23%

The Dusting Disaster award for the worst sugar.

See the judges’ scores

Judges	Looks	Sugar	Pastry	Filling	Value	Total
Andy						68.64%
Dave						46.53%
Fraser						47.73%
Heather						55.74%
Jade						60.62%
Katy						53.86%
Kirsty						52.16%
Lewis						48.81%
Pete						49.37%
Rob						38.86%
Total	55%	29%	58%	55%	62%	52.23%

See more of this pie

Looks: 73%
Sugar: 48%
Pastry: 73%
Filling: 79%
Value: 80%
Total: 71.58%

See the judges’ scores

Judges	Looks	Sugar	Pastry	Filling	Value	Total
Andy						71.19%
Dave						65.91%
Fraser						62.33%
Heather						74.89%
Jade						80.62%
Katy						84.66%
Kirsty						64.15%
Lewis						72.33%
Pete						75.74%
Rob						63.98%
Total	73%	48%	73%	79%	80%	71.58%

See more of this pie

Asda

Looks: 66%
Sugar: 55%
Pastry: 64%
Filling: 59%
Value: 82%
Total: 62.98%

See the judges’ scores

Judges	Looks	Sugar	Pastry	Filling	Value	Total
Andy						86.02%
Dave						73.46%
Fraser						61.76%
Heather						78.01%
Jade						71.70%
Katy						68.07%
Kirsty						62.95%
Lewis						37.38%
Pete						35.91%
Rob						54.48%
Total	66%	55%	64%	59%	82%	62.98%

See more of this pie

TescoPlant Chef

Looks: 30%
Sugar: 44%
Pastry: 51%
Filling: 51%
Value: 45%
Total: 47.34%

The Ugliest Pie award for the worst looks.

See the judges’ scores

Judges	Looks	Sugar	Pastry	Filling	Value	Total
Andy						48.35%
Dave						46.25%
Fraser						31.36%
Heather						44.09%
Jade						41.19%
Katy						40.68%
Kirsty						38.30%
Lewis						69.72%
Pete						61.42%
Rob						51.99%
Total	30%	44%	51%	51%	45%	47.34%

See more of this pie

Looks: 89%
Sugar: 72%
Pastry: 83%
Filling: 76%
Value: 76%
Total: 79.56%

The Picture-Perfect Pie award for the best looks.

See the judges’ scores

Judges	Looks	Sugar	Pastry	Filling	Value	Total
Andy						68.52%
Dave						77.10%
Fraser						89.49%
Heather						61.70%
Jade						78.47%
Katy						73.87%
Kirsty						86.36%
Lewis						83.24%
Pete						77.44%
Rob						88.35%
Total	89%	72%	83%	76%	76%	79.56%

See more of this pie

Co-opIrresistible

Looks: 31%
Sugar: 39%
Pastry: 61%
Filling: 58%
Value: 39%
Total: 51.17%

See the judges’ scores

Judges	Looks	Sugar	Pastry	Filling	Value	Total
Andy						33.13%
Dave						65.97%
Fraser						48.35%
Heather						38.30%
Jade						62.39%
Katy						43.53%
Kirsty						52.62%
Lewis						64.21%
Pete						52.33%
Rob						50.91%
Total	31%	39%	61%	58%	39%	51.17%

See more of this pie

Looks: 77%
Sugar: 84%
Pastry: 85%
Filling: 86%
Value: 89%
Total: 84.94%

The Sweet Spot award for the best sugar.
The Flakiest Favourite award for the best pastry.
The Merriest Mincemeat award for the best filling.
The Value Victor award for the best value.

See the judges’ scores

Judges	Looks	Sugar	Pastry	Filling	Value	Total
Andy						89.09%
Dave						75.74%
Fraser						73.69%
Heather						83.18%
Jade						74.26%
Katy						84.66%
Kirsty						94.89%
Lewis						94.26%
Pete						88.30%
Rob						91.36%
Total	77%	84%	85%	86%	89%	84.94%

See more of this pie

AsdaLuxury Sloe Gin

Looks: 60%
Sugar: 52%
Pastry: 69%
Filling: 55%
Value: 58%
Total: 59.31%

See the judges’ scores

Judges	Looks	Sugar	Pastry	Filling	Value	Total
Andy						73.41%
Dave						60.62%
Fraser						52.90%
Heather						85.46%
Jade						46.31%
Katy						76.65%
Kirsty						44.66%
Lewis						53.24%
Pete						53.24%
Rob						46.65%
Total	60%	52%	69%	55%	58%	59.31%

See more of this pie

Morrisons

Looks: 50%
Sugar: 46%
Pastry: 70%
Filling: 71%
Value: 81%
Total: 65.79%

See the judges’ scores

Judges	Looks	Sugar	Pastry	Filling	Value	Total
Andy						70.28%
Dave						63.75%
Fraser						63.46%
Heather						67.38%
Jade						66.87%
Katy						82.10%
Kirsty						62.27%
Lewis						63.47%
Pete						60.05%
Rob						58.29%
Total	50%	46%	70%	71%	81%	65.79%

See more of this pie

Sainsbury’s

Looks: 44%
Sugar: 42%
Pastry: 18%
Filling: 22%
Value: 26%
Total: 26.58%

The Crust Catastrophe award for the worst pastry.
The Filling Fail award for the worst filling.
The Wallet Waster award for the worst value.
The Festive Flop award for the worst overall score.

See the judges’ scores

Judges	Looks	Sugar	Pastry	Filling	Value	Total
Andy						26.82%
Dave						39.09%
Fraser						28.24%
Heather						17.10%
Jade						35.34%
Katy						0.00%
Kirsty						23.41%
Lewis						36.48%
Pete						30.23%
Rob						29.09%
Total	44%	42%	18%	22%	26%	26.58%

See more of this pie

Iceland

Looks: 44%
Sugar: 64%
Pastry: 62%
Filling: 64%
Value: 70%
Total: 62.4%

See the judges’ scores

Judges	Looks	Sugar	Pastry	Filling	Value	Total
Andy						68.58%
Dave						71.48%
Fraser						63.18%
Heather						66.02%
Jade						63.35%
Katy						48.81%
Kirsty						65.68%
Lewis						59.15%
Pete						61.99%
Rob						55.74%
Total	44%	64%	62%	64%	70%	62.40%

See more of this pie

Sainsbury’sTaste the Difference

Looks: 76%
Sugar: 53%
Pastry: 77%
Filling: 69%
Value: 54%
Total: 67.48%

See the judges’ scores

Judges	Looks	Sugar	Pastry	Filling	Value	Total
Andy						70.57%
Dave						73.98%
Fraser						73.47%
Heather						62.27%
Jade						78.41%
Katy						64.21%
Kirsty						47.38%
Lewis						67.45%
Pete						68.35%
Rob						68.75%
Total	76%	53%	77%	69%	54%	67.48%

See more of this pie

2021Pelosi Mince
Pie Inquiry

AldiSpecially Selected

LidlDeluxe

Asda

TescoPlant Chef

TescoFinest

Co-opIrresistible

M&SClassic

AsdaLuxury Sloe Gin

Morrisons

Sainsbury’s

Iceland

Sainsbury’sTaste the Difference

The year in graphs