M&SThe Collection

Looks
58%
Sugar
63%
Pastry
52%
Filling
78%
Value
53%
Total
63.69%
See the judges’ scores
JudgesLooksSugarPastryFillingValueTotal
Andrew58.92%
Calum78.58%
Emma BB68.18%
Emma S60.34%
Euan51.25%
Heather66.82%
Jade74.60%
Keenan83.41%
Kirsty65.68%
Lewis53.64%
Marc60.17%
Michelle48.07%
Molly59.89%
Pete64.83%
Raymond64.55%
Rob61.14%
Ross57.90%
Stephen57.05%
Total58%63%52%78%53%63.69%
See more of this pie

Sainsbury’sTaste the Difference

Looks
74%
Sugar
51%
Pastry
63%
Filling
51%
Value
58%
Total
57.4%
See the judges’ scores
JudgesLooksSugarPastryFillingValueTotal
Andrew54.89%
Calum43.41%
Emma BB66.36%
Emma S68.24%
Euan60.68%
Heather33.18%
Jade38.30%
Keenan56.59%
Kirsty48.01%
Lewis72.05%
Marc66.25%
Michelle62.61%
Molly55.40%
Pete61.25%
Raymond42.39%
Rob72.33%
Ross71.33%
Stephen53.75%
Total74%51%63%51%58%57.40%
See more of this pie

IcelandLuxury

Looks
68%
Sugar
61%
Pastry
65%
Filling
63%
Value
76%
Total
65.57%
See the judges’ scores
JudgesLooksSugarPastryFillingValueTotal
Andrew72.50%
Calum64.49%
Emma BB74.89%
Emma S69.72%
Euan58.92%
Heather68.81%
Jade57.16%
Keenan78.86%
Kirsty60.34%
Lewis60.62%
Marc55.91%
Michelle65.17%
Molly71.48%
Pete75.17%
Raymond78.30%
Rob37.44%
Ross71.93%
Stephen56.19%
Total68%61%65%63%76%65.57%
See more of this pie

Greggs

Looks
28%
Sugar
30%
Pastry
42%
Filling
42%
Value
45%
Total
39.05%
See the judges’ scores
JudgesLooksSugarPastryFillingValueTotal
Andrew89.77%
Calum26.82%
Emma BB39.54%
Emma S56.36%
Euan29.77%
Heather54.89%
Jade34.60%
Keenan38.18%
Kirsty37.72%
Lewis16.02%
Marc53.58%
Michelle42.87%
Molly60.68%
Pete21.70%
Raymond60.00%
Rob14.32%
Ross37.81%
Stephen39.15%
Total28%30%42%42%45%39.05%
See more of this pie

Tesco

Looks
61%
Sugar
52%
Pastry
60%
Filling
61%
Value
96%
Total
63.01%
See the judges’ scores
JudgesLooksSugarPastryFillingValueTotal
Andrew20.00%
Calum67.95%
Emma BB70.34%
Emma S61.13%
Euan54.65%
Jade68.01%
Keenan50.22%
Kirsty59.94%
Lewis60.79%
Marc55.45%
Michelle68.80%
Molly68.63%
Pete61.13%
Raymond62.27%
Rob71.36%
Ross64.51%
Stephen62.15%
Total61%52%60%61%96%63.01%
See more of this pie

TescoFinest

Looks
90%
Sugar
67%
Pastry
86%
Filling
76%
Value
84%
Total
79.49%
See the judges’ scores
JudgesLooksSugarPastryFillingValueTotal
Andrew82.05%
Calum80.85%
Emma BB74.32%
Emma S74.89%
Euan80.85%
Heather75.17%
Jade82.33%
Keenan80.00%
Kirsty85.68%
Lewis80.68%
Marc78.30%
Michelle84.37%
Molly75.57%
Pete82.05%
Raymond70.62%
Rob87.50%
Ross78.66%
Total90%67%86%76%84%79.49%
See more of this pie

MorrisonsThe Best

Looks
70%
Sugar
51%
Pastry
65%
Filling
67%
Value
58%
Total
62.98%
See the judges’ scores
JudgesLooksSugarPastryFillingValueTotal
Calum81.82%
Emma BB58.18%
Emma S41.14%
Euan60.46%
Heather75.17%
Jade46.87%
Keenan74.03%
Kirsty61.53%
Lewis55.46%
Marc50.79%
Michelle60.00%
Molly65.74%
Pete81.76%
Raymond68.52%
Rob60.68%
Ross65.46%
Total70%51%65%67%58%62.98%
See more of this pie

Mr. KiplingDeep Filled

Looks
87%
Sugar
57%
Pastry
71%
Filling
58%
Value
76%
Total
66.12%
See the judges’ scores
JudgesLooksSugarPastryFillingValueTotal
Calum66.65%
Emma BB68.07%
Emma S54.89%
Euan76.02%
Heather74.89%
Jade74.89%
Keenan51.93%
Kirsty55.45%
Lewis62.27%
Michelle73.75%
Molly68.07%
Pete55.45%
Raymond66.36%
Rob76.59%
Ross66.59%
Total87%57%71%58%76%66.12%
See more of this pie

M&SClassic

Looks
58%
Sugar
74%
Pastry
82%
Filling
81%
Value
75%
Total
77.53%
See the judges’ scores
JudgesLooksSugarPastryFillingValueTotal
Calum83.61%
Emma BB80.00%
Emma S62.39%
Euan90.91%
Heather87.50%
Jade83.80%
Keenan94.03%
Kirsty54.89%
Lewis82.62%
Marc63.41%
Michelle87.50%
Molly78.30%
Pete72.90%
Raymond87.50%
Rob54.15%
Ross76.96%
Total58%74%82%81%75%77.53%
See more of this pie

AldiSpecially Selected

Looks
74%
Sugar
48%
Pastry
60%
Filling
49%
Value
64%
Total
55.71%
See the judges’ scores
JudgesLooksSugarPastryFillingValueTotal
Calum51.42%
Emma BB60.57%
Emma S64.66%
Euan37.38%
Heather62.67%
Jade63.98%
Keenan65.80%
Kirsty72.04%
Lewis52.05%
Michelle49.77%
Molly53.75%
Pete51.48%
Raymond42.84%
Rob59.15%
Ross48.10%
Total74%48%60%49%64%55.71%
See more of this pie

LidlDeluxe

Looks
68%
Sugar
81%
Pastry
73%
Filling
73%
Value
95%
Total
76.42%
See the judges’ scores
JudgesLooksSugarPastryFillingValueTotal
Calum82.27%
Emma BB82.27%
Emma S78.30%
Euan82.27%
Heather74.77%
Keenan58.86%
Lewis82.27%
Michelle81.08%
Molly80.57%
Pete83.98%
Raymond62.27%
Rob67.10%
Ross77.41%
Total68%81%73%73%95%76.42%
See more of this pie

Asda

Looks
48%
Sugar
64%
Pastry
49%
Filling
44%
Value
58%
Total
47.33%
See the judges’ scores
JudgesLooksSugarPastryFillingValueTotal
Calum53.41%
Emma BB11.59%
Emma S72.04%
Heather60.11%
Keenan52.50%
Lewis37.73%
Michelle33.92%
Pete44.55%
Raymond43.41%
Rob48.52%
Ross62.89%
Total48%64%49%44%58%47.33%
See more of this pie

Waitrose

Looks
93%
Sugar
88%
Pastry
79%
Filling
70%
Value
44%
Total
74.64%
See the judges’ scores
JudgesLooksSugarPastryFillingValueTotal
Emma S60.57%
Heather75.46%
Keenan62.96%
Lewis78.30%
Pete80.57%
Raymond88.64%
Rob79.43%
Ross71.17%
Total93%88%79%70%44%74.64%
See more of this pie

The year in graphs

Graph Data:

M&S: The Collection
Total63.69%
Price£2.50
Looks57.65%
Sugar62.94%
Pastry52.35%
Filling77.65%
Value52.94%
Sainsbury’s: Taste the Difference
Total57.4%
Price£2.00
Looks74.41%
Sugar51.47%
Pastry62.94%
Filling50.59%
Value57.94%
Iceland: Luxury
Total65.57%
Price£1.89
Looks67.65%
Sugar61.18%
Pastry64.71%
Filling62.94%
Value75.88%
Greggs
Total39.05%
Price£1.75
Looks27.65%
Sugar30%
Pastry42.35%
Filling41.76%
Value44.71%
Tesco
Total63.01%
Price£0.89
Looks61.25%
Sugar51.88%
Pastry59.69%
Filling60.63%
Value96.25%
Tesco: Finest
Total79.49%
Price£1.75
Looks90.31%
Sugar66.88%
Pastry85.63%
Filling76.25%
Value84.38%
Morrisons: The Best
Total62.98%
Price£2.00
Looks70%
Sugar50.63%
Pastry65%
Filling67.19%
Value58.44%
Mr. Kipling: Deep Filled
Total66.12%
Price£1.70
Looks86.67%
Sugar56.67%
Pastry71.33%
Filling58%
Value76%
M&S: Classic
Total77.53%
Price£1.80
Looks57.81%
Sugar73.75%
Pastry82.19%
Filling81.13%
Value75.31%
Aldi: Specially Selected
Total55.71%
Price£1.39
Looks73.67%
Sugar48%
Pastry60%
Filling48.67%
Value64%
Lidl: Deluxe
Total76.42%
Price£1.25
Looks68.46%
Sugar80.77%
Pastry72.69%
Filling73.08%
Value95.38%
Asda
Total47.33%
Price£0.87
Looks48%
Sugar64%
Pastry49.09%
Filling43.5%
Value58%
Waitrose
Total74.64%
Price£2.50
Looks92.5%
Sugar87.5%
Pastry79.38%
Filling70%
Value43.75%