2019 Pelosi Mince Pie Inquiry

M&SThe Collection

Looks: 58%
Sugar: 63%
Pastry: 52%
Filling: 78%
Value: 53%
Total: 63.69%

See the judges’ scores

Judges	Looks	Sugar	Pastry	Filling	Value	Total
Andrew						58.92%
Calum						78.58%
Emma BB						68.18%
Emma S						60.34%
Euan						51.25%
Heather						66.82%
Jade						74.60%
Keenan						83.41%
Kirsty						65.68%
Lewis						53.64%
Marc						60.17%
Michelle						48.07%
Molly						59.89%
Pete						64.83%
Raymond						64.55%
Rob						61.14%
Ross						57.90%
Stephen						57.05%
Total	58%	63%	52%	78%	53%	63.69%

See more of this pie

Sainsbury’sTaste the Difference

Looks: 74%
Sugar: 51%
Pastry: 63%
Filling: 51%
Value: 58%
Total: 57.4%

See the judges’ scores

Judges	Looks	Sugar	Pastry	Filling	Value	Total
Andrew						54.89%
Calum						43.41%
Emma BB						66.36%
Emma S						68.24%
Euan						60.68%
Heather						33.18%
Jade						38.30%
Keenan						56.59%
Kirsty						48.01%
Lewis						72.05%
Marc						66.25%
Michelle						62.61%
Molly						55.40%
Pete						61.25%
Raymond						42.39%
Rob						72.33%
Ross						71.33%
Stephen						53.75%
Total	74%	51%	63%	51%	58%	57.40%

See more of this pie

IcelandLuxury

Looks: 68%
Sugar: 61%
Pastry: 65%
Filling: 63%
Value: 76%
Total: 65.57%

See the judges’ scores

Judges	Looks	Sugar	Pastry	Filling	Value	Total
Andrew						72.50%
Calum						64.49%
Emma BB						74.89%
Emma S						69.72%
Euan						58.92%
Heather						68.81%
Jade						57.16%
Keenan						78.86%
Kirsty						60.34%
Lewis						60.62%
Marc						55.91%
Michelle						65.17%
Molly						71.48%
Pete						75.17%
Raymond						78.30%
Rob						37.44%
Ross						71.93%
Stephen						56.19%
Total	68%	61%	65%	63%	76%	65.57%

See more of this pie

Greggs

Looks: 28%
Sugar: 30%
Pastry: 42%
Filling: 42%
Value: 45%
Total: 39.05%

The Ugliest Pie award for the worst looks.
The Dusting Disaster award for the worst sugar.
The Crust Catastrophe award for the worst pastry.
The Filling Fail award for the worst filling.
The Festive Flop award for the worst overall score.

See the judges’ scores

Judges	Looks	Sugar	Pastry	Filling	Value	Total
Andrew						89.77%
Calum						26.82%
Emma BB						39.54%
Emma S						56.36%
Euan						29.77%
Heather						54.89%
Jade						34.60%
Keenan						38.18%
Kirsty						37.72%
Lewis						16.02%
Marc						53.58%
Michelle						42.87%
Molly						60.68%
Pete						21.70%
Raymond						60.00%
Rob						14.32%
Ross						37.81%
Stephen						39.15%
Total	28%	30%	42%	42%	45%	39.05%

See more of this pie

Tesco

Looks: 61%
Sugar: 52%
Pastry: 60%
Filling: 61%
Value: 96%
Total: 63.01%

The Value Victor award for the best value.

See the judges’ scores

Judges	Looks	Sugar	Pastry	Filling	Value	Total
Andrew						20.00%
Calum						67.95%
Emma BB						70.34%
Emma S						61.13%
Euan						54.65%
Jade						68.01%
Keenan						50.22%
Kirsty						59.94%
Lewis						60.79%
Marc						55.45%
Michelle						68.80%
Molly						68.63%
Pete						61.13%
Raymond						62.27%
Rob						71.36%
Ross						64.51%
Stephen						62.15%
Total	61%	52%	60%	61%	96%	63.01%

See more of this pie

Looks: 90%
Sugar: 67%
Pastry: 86%
Filling: 76%
Value: 84%
Total: 79.49%

The Flakiest Favourite award for the best pastry.

See the judges’ scores

Judges	Looks	Sugar	Pastry	Filling	Value	Total
Andrew						82.05%
Calum						80.85%
Emma BB						74.32%
Emma S						74.89%
Euan						80.85%
Heather						75.17%
Jade						82.33%
Keenan						80.00%
Kirsty						85.68%
Lewis						80.68%
Marc						78.30%
Michelle						84.37%
Molly						75.57%
Pete						82.05%
Raymond						70.62%
Rob						87.50%
Ross						78.66%
Total	90%	67%	86%	76%	84%	79.49%

See more of this pie

MorrisonsThe Best

Looks: 70%
Sugar: 51%
Pastry: 65%
Filling: 67%
Value: 58%
Total: 62.98%

See the judges’ scores

Judges	Looks	Sugar	Pastry	Filling	Value	Total
Calum						81.82%
Emma BB						58.18%
Emma S						41.14%
Euan						60.46%
Heather						75.17%
Jade						46.87%
Keenan						74.03%
Kirsty						61.53%
Lewis						55.46%
Marc						50.79%
Michelle						60.00%
Molly						65.74%
Pete						81.76%
Raymond						68.52%
Rob						60.68%
Ross						65.46%
Total	70%	51%	65%	67%	58%	62.98%

See more of this pie

Mr. KiplingDeep Filled

Looks: 87%
Sugar: 57%
Pastry: 71%
Filling: 58%
Value: 76%
Total: 66.12%

See the judges’ scores

Judges	Looks	Sugar	Pastry	Filling	Value	Total
Calum						66.65%
Emma BB						68.07%
Emma S						54.89%
Euan						76.02%
Heather						74.89%
Jade						74.89%
Keenan						51.93%
Kirsty						55.45%
Lewis						62.27%
Michelle						73.75%
Molly						68.07%
Pete						55.45%
Raymond						66.36%
Rob						76.59%
Ross						66.59%
Total	87%	57%	71%	58%	76%	66.12%

See more of this pie

Looks: 58%
Sugar: 74%
Pastry: 82%
Filling: 81%
Value: 75%
Total: 77.53%

The Merriest Mincemeat award for the best filling.

See the judges’ scores

Judges	Looks	Sugar	Pastry	Filling	Value	Total
Calum						83.61%
Emma BB						80.00%
Emma S						62.39%
Euan						90.91%
Heather						87.50%
Jade						83.80%
Keenan						94.03%
Kirsty						54.89%
Lewis						82.62%
Marc						63.41%
Michelle						87.50%
Molly						78.30%
Pete						72.90%
Raymond						87.50%
Rob						54.15%
Ross						76.96%
Total	58%	74%	82%	81%	75%	77.53%

See more of this pie

AldiSpecially Selected

Looks: 74%
Sugar: 48%
Pastry: 60%
Filling: 49%
Value: 64%
Total: 55.71%

See the judges’ scores

Judges	Looks	Sugar	Pastry	Filling	Value	Total
Calum						51.42%
Emma BB						60.57%
Emma S						64.66%
Euan						37.38%
Heather						62.67%
Jade						63.98%
Keenan						65.80%
Kirsty						72.04%
Lewis						52.05%
Michelle						49.77%
Molly						53.75%
Pete						51.48%
Raymond						42.84%
Rob						59.15%
Ross						48.10%
Total	74%	48%	60%	49%	64%	55.71%

See more of this pie

Looks: 68%
Sugar: 81%
Pastry: 73%
Filling: 73%
Value: 95%
Total: 76.42%

See the judges’ scores

Judges	Looks	Sugar	Pastry	Filling	Value	Total
Calum						82.27%
Emma BB						82.27%
Emma S						78.30%
Euan						82.27%
Heather						74.77%
Keenan						58.86%
Lewis						82.27%
Michelle						81.08%
Molly						80.57%
Pete						83.98%
Raymond						62.27%
Rob						67.10%
Ross						77.41%
Total	68%	81%	73%	73%	95%	76.42%

See more of this pie

Asda

Looks: 48%
Sugar: 64%
Pastry: 49%
Filling: 44%
Value: 58%
Total: 47.33%

See the judges’ scores

Judges	Looks	Sugar	Pastry	Filling	Value	Total
Calum						53.41%
Emma BB						11.59%
Emma S						72.04%
Heather						60.11%
Keenan						52.50%
Lewis						37.73%
Michelle						33.92%
Pete						44.55%
Raymond						43.41%
Rob						48.52%
Ross						62.89%
Total	48%	64%	49%	44%	58%	47.33%