MorrisonsThe Best

Looks
45%
Sugar
47%
Pastry
40%
Filling
47%
Value
42%
Total
44.02%
See the judges’ scores
JudgesLooksSugarPastryFillingValueTotal
Andrew54.89%
Asa35.34%
Brian43.41%
Emma55.46%
Euan40.17%
Fraser32.50%
Stephen34.89%
Jade37.95%
Lewis47.95%
Mike37.73%
Niall56.59%
Pete51.42%
Total45%47%40%47%42%44.02%
See more of this pie

IcelandLuxury

Looks
61%
Sugar
56%
Pastry
68%
Filling
60%
Value
60%
Total
61.78%
See the judges’ scores
JudgesLooksSugarPastryFillingValueTotal
Andrew34.32%
Asa68.07%
Brian58.30%
Emma69.09%
Euan67.50%
Fraser62.05%
Stephen64.09%
Jade69.77%
Lewis65.11%
Mike69.77%
Niall53.12%
Pete60.12%
Total61%56%68%60%60%61.78%
See more of this pie

Greggs

Looks
37%
Sugar
31%
Pastry
68%
Filling
67%
Value
55%
Total
57.16%
See the judges’ scores
JudgesLooksSugarPastryFillingValueTotal
Andrew62.39%
Asa50.34%
Brian45.80%
Emma68.52%
Euan54.43%
Fraser58.98%
Stephen54.32%
Jade60.57%
Lewis64.09%
Mike56.59%
Niall51.19%
Pete58.69%
Total37%31%68%67%55%57.16%
See more of this pie

M&SClassic

Looks
59%
Sugar
60%
Pastry
64%
Filling
65%
Value
49%
Total
61.6%
See the judges’ scores
JudgesLooksSugarPastryFillingValueTotal
Andrew73.07%
Asa77.62%
Brian52.62%
Emma70.86%
Fraser55.17%
Stephen51.48%
Jade47.50%
Lewis37.45%
Mike72.62%
Niall69.15%
Pete70.06%
Total59%60%64%65%49%61.60%
See more of this pie

AsdaExtra Special

Looks
56%
Sugar
22%
Pastry
44%
Filling
52%
Value
41%
Total
43.5%
See the judges’ scores
JudgesLooksSugarPastryFillingValueTotal
Andrew25.80%
Asa40.45%
Brian42.39%
Emma35.57%
Euan24.60%
Fraser38.30%
Stephen45.11%
Jade47.10%
Lewis62.79%
Mike46.82%
Niall60.91%
Pete52.22%
Total56%22%44%52%41%43.50%
See more of this pie

TescoFinest

Looks
78%
Sugar
75%
Pastry
64%
Filling
74%
Value
68%
Total
70.82%
See the judges’ scores
JudgesLooksSugarPastryFillingValueTotal
Asa73.18%
Brian72.50%
Emma76.59%
Euan81.88%
Fraser77.44%
Stephen57.44%
Jade67.21%
Lewis75.85%
Mike76.20%
Niall77.95%
Pete42.73%
Total78%75%64%74%68%70.82%
See more of this pie

LidlDeluxe

Looks
82%
Sugar
82%
Pastry
70%
Filling
86%
Value
92%
Total
81.02%
See the judges’ scores
JudgesLooksSugarPastryFillingValueTotal
Asa72.50%
Brian81.88%
Emma90.85%
Fraser80.23%
Stephen78.18%
Jade80.23%
Lewis86.19%
Mike73.07%
Niall84.83%
Pete82.27%
Total82%82%70%86%92%81.02%
See more of this pie

Tesco

Looks
53%
Sugar
48%
Pastry
63%
Filling
64%
Value
81%
Total
61.65%
See the judges’ scores
JudgesLooksSugarPastryFillingValueTotal
Asa55.46%
Brian53.75%
Emma58.35%
Stephen73.12%
Jade75.11%
Lewis59.77%
Mike50.79%
Pete66.82%
Total53%48%63%64%81%61.65%
See more of this pie

Co-opIrresistible

Looks
75%
Sugar
40%
Pastry
48%
Filling
43%
Value
44%
Total
46.78%
See the judges’ scores
JudgesLooksSugarPastryFillingValueTotal
Asa52.05%
Brian40.00%
Emma48.52%
Euan41.70%
Fraser47.10%
Stephen37.10%
Jade73.52%
Lewis39.26%
Mike41.02%
Pete47.50%
Total75%40%48%43%44%46.78%
See more of this pie

Waitrose

Looks
44%
Sugar
14%
Pastry
74%
Filling
66%
Value
40%
Total
54.58%
See the judges’ scores
JudgesLooksSugarPastryFillingValueTotal
Asa53.75%
Brian62.39%
Emma68.64%
Euan62.39%
Jade52.67%
Lewis35.85%
Mike51.59%
Pete49.32%
Total44%14%74%66%40%54.58%
See more of this pie

Sainsbury’sTaste the Difference

Looks
96%
Sugar
32%
Pastry
92%
Filling
90%
Value
84%
Total
80.43%
See the judges’ scores
JudgesLooksSugarPastryFillingValueTotal
Asa78.98%
Brian74.89%
Emma58.41%
Euan88.64%
Fraser80.62%
Stephen84.09%
Jade80.62%
Lewis76.02%
Mike77.21%
Niall100.00%
Pete85.23%
Total96%32%92%90%84%80.43%
See more of this pie

The year in graphs

Graph Data:

Morrisons: The Best
Total44.02%
Price£2.00
Looks45%
Sugar46.67%
Pastry40%
Filling46.67%
Value41.67%
Iceland: Luxury
Total61.78%
Price£1.79
Looks60.83%
Sugar55.83%
Pastry68.33%
Filling60%
Value60%
Greggs
Total57.16%
Price£1.75
Looks36.67%
Sugar30.83%
Pastry68.33%
Filling66.67%
Value55%
M&S: Classic
Total61.6%
Price£1.99
Looks59.09%
Sugar60%
Pastry63.64%
Filling65.45%
Value49.09%
Asda: Extra Special
Total43.5%
Price£2.00
Looks55.83%
Sugar21.67%
Pastry44.17%
Filling51.67%
Value40.83%
Tesco: Finest
Total70.82%
Price£2.00
Looks78.18%
Sugar75.45%
Pastry63.64%
Filling73.64%
Value68.18%
Lidl: Deluxe
Total81.02%
Price£1.49
Looks82%
Sugar82%
Pastry70%
Filling86%
Value92%
Tesco
Total61.65%
Price£1.00
Looks52.5%
Sugar47.5%
Pastry62.5%
Filling63.75%
Value81.25%
Co-op: Irresistible
Total46.78%
Price£2.00
Looks75%
Sugar40%
Pastry48%
Filling43%
Value44%
Waitrose
Total54.58%
Price£2.50
Looks43.75%
Sugar13.75%
Pastry73.75%
Filling66.25%
Value40%
Sainsbury’s: Taste the Difference
Total80.43%
Price£1.75
Looks96.36%
Sugar31.82%
Pastry91.82%
Filling90%
Value83.64%