MincePie.fyi

Past years’
results.

All time best

Waitrose: All Butter (2023)

All time worst

Sainsbury’s (2021)

Current best

M&S: Classic (2025)

Current worst

Iceland (2025)

Averages over the years.

Graph Data:

2016
Total62.52%
Price£1.66
Looks0%
Sugar59.5%
Pastry64.17%
Filling55%
Value0%
2017
Total60.3%
Price£1.84
Looks62.29%
Sugar45.96%
Pastry63.11%
Filling64.83%
Value59.61%
2018
Total64.79%
Price£1.90
Looks72.56%
Sugar62.04%
Pastry63.89%
Filling63.66%
Value62.08%
2019
Total63.77%
Price£1.71
Looks67.39%
Sugar60.43%
Pastry65.18%
Filling62.41%
Value67.92%
2020
Total57.84%
Price£1.57
Looks64.33%
Sugar45.37%
Pastry61.15%
Filling59.81%
Value59.62%
2021
Total60.95%
Price£1.52
Looks57.92%
Sugar52.33%
Pastry64.25%
Filling62.08%
Value63.5%
2022
Total63.34%
Price£2.05
Looks60.76%
Sugar54.72%
Pastry62.99%
Filling69.03%
Value63.06%
2023
Total62.23%
Price£2.31
Looks58.19%
Sugar59.86%
Pastry65.35%
Filling62.71%
Value59.79%
2024
Total63.28%
Price£2.71
Looks64.54%
Sugar55.44%
Pastry62.59%
Filling67.5%
Value63.22%
2025
Total59.49%
Price£2.33
Looks61.11%
Sugar53.43%
Pastry60.94%
Filling60.51%
Value62.74%

2025

  1. A gold medal for 1st place.M&S: Classic
  2. A silver medal for 2nd place.Waitrose: All Butter
  3. A bronze medal for 3rd place.Morrisons: The Best
  4. Sainsbury’s: Taste the Difference
  5. Lidl: Deluxe
  6. Aldi: Specially Selected
  7. Asda: Exceptional
  8. Waitrose: No.1 Brown Butter with Cognac
  9. Sainsbury’s
  10. Morrisons
  11. Asda: OMV!
  12. Iceland

2024

  1. A gold medal for 1st place.Waitrose: All Butter
  2. A silver medal for 2nd place.M&S: Classic
  3. A bronze medal for 3rd place.Tesco: Finest
  4. Lidl: Deluxe
  5. M&S: The Collection
  6. Sainsbury’s: Taste the Difference
  7. Aldi: Specially Selected
  8. Waitrose: No.1 Brown Butter with Cognac
  9. Mr. Kipling: Deep Filled
  10. Aldi: Specially Selected Frangipane
  11. Lidl: Favorina
  12. Morrisons: The Best

2023

  1. A gold medal for 1st place.Waitrose: All Butter
  2. A silver medal for 2nd place.Iceland: Luxury
  3. A bronze medal for 3rd place.Lidl: Deluxe
  4. Sainsbury’s: Taste the Difference
  5. M&S: The Collection
  6. M&S: Puff Pastry
  7. Co-op: Irresistible
  8. Tesco: Finest
  9. Sainsbury’s
  10. Co-op
  11. Waitrose: Essential
  12. Tesco

2022

  1. A gold medal for 1st place.M&S: Classic
  2. A silver medal for 2nd place.Tesco: Finest
  3. A bronze medal for 3rd place.Morrisons: The Best
  4. Sainsbury’s: Taste the Difference
  5. Asda: Extra Special
  6. M&S: The Collection
  7. Lidl: Deluxe
  8. Iceland
  9. Co-op: Irresistible
  10. Morrisons
  11. Tesco Finest: Spiced Rum
  12. Mr. Kipling: Deep Filled

2021

  1. A gold medal for 1st place.M&S: Classic
  2. A silver medal for 2nd place.Tesco: Finest
  3. A bronze medal for 3rd place.Lidl: Deluxe
  4. Sainsbury’s: Taste the Difference
  5. Morrisons
  6. Asda
  7. Iceland
  8. Asda: Luxury Sloe Gin
  9. Aldi: Specially Selected
  10. Co-op: Irresistible
  11. Tesco: Plant Chef
  12. Sainsbury’s

2020

  1. A gold medal for 1st place.M&S: Classic
  2. A silver medal for 2nd place.Lidl: Deluxe
  3. A bronze medal for 3rd place.Aldi: Specially Selected
  4. Asda: Extra Special
  5. M&S: Puff Pastry
  6. Tesco
  7. Co-op
  8. Sainsbury’s: Taste the Difference
  9. Mr. Kipling: Deep Filled
  10. Morrisons: The Best
  11. Tesco: Finest “Crumble”
  12. Aldi: Holly Lane

2019

  1. A gold medal for 1st place.Tesco: Finest
  2. A silver medal for 2nd place.M&S: Classic
  3. A bronze medal for 3rd place.Lidl: Deluxe
  4. Waitrose: All Butter
  5. Mr. Kipling: Deep Filled
  6. Iceland: Luxury
  7. M&S: The Collection
  8. Tesco
  9. Morrisons: The Best
  10. Sainsbury’s: Taste the Difference
  11. Aldi: Specially Selected
  12. Asda
  13. Greggs

2018

  1. A gold medal for 1st place.Lidl: Deluxe
  2. A silver medal for 2nd place.Iceland: Luxury
  3. A bronze medal for 3rd place.M&S: The Collection
  4. Morrisons: The Best
  5. M&S: Classic
  6. Aldi: Specially Selected
  7. Co-op: Irresistible
  8. Tesco Finest: Spiced Rum
  9. Mr. Kipling: Deep Filled
  10. Sainsbury’s: Taste the Difference
  11. Asda: Extra Special
  12. Morrisons: Bakery

2017

  1. A gold medal for 1st place.Lidl: Deluxe
  2. A silver medal for 2nd place.Sainsbury’s: Taste the Difference
  3. A bronze medal for 3rd place.Tesco: Finest
  4. Iceland: Luxury
  5. Tesco
  6. M&S: Classic
  7. Greggs
  8. Waitrose: All Butter
  9. Co-op: Irresistible
  10. Morrisons: The Best
  11. Asda: Extra Special

2016

  1. A gold medal for 1st place.Asda: Extra Special
  2. A silver medal for 2nd place.Co-op: Irresistible
  3. A bronze medal for 3rd place.Lidl: Deluxe
  4. M&S: The Collection
  5. Sainsbury’s: Taste the Difference
  6. Tesco: Finest
  7. Morrisons: The Best
  8. Iceland: Luxury
  9. Greggs
  10. Tesco