2025WaitroseNo.1 Brown Butter with Cognac

Looks
29%
Sugar
25%
Pastry
74%
Filling
59%
Value
57%
Total
54.7%
  • The Ugliest Pie award for the worst looks.
  • The Dusting Disaster award for the worst sugar.
See the judges’ scores
JudgesLooksSugarPastryFillingValueTotal
Andy48.01%
Claire62.05%
Dave68.07%
Emma69.77%
Euan62.39%
Fraser62.73%
Heather39.72%
Jade37.39%
Jeff62.95%
Katie44.89%
Katy34.66%
Kirsty21.70%
Lewis72.73%
Lucy38.01%
Michelle36.59%
Mike74.94%
Pete63.92%
Phil64.54%
Rob74.20%
Total29%25%74%59%57%54.70%

2024WaitroseNo.1 Brown Butter with Cognac

Looks
31%
Sugar
52%
Pastry
74%
Filling
64%
Value
43%
Total
59.67%
  • The Ugliest Pie award for the worst looks.
See the judges’ scores
JudgesLooksSugarPastryFillingValueTotal
Andy57.28%
Dave51.71%
Emma63.53%
Euan50.97%
Fraser61.25%
Heather19.15%
Jade64.66%
Jeff49.83%
Katie70.74%
Katy57.39%
Kirsty57.27%
Lewis70.63%
Lucy64.60%
Michelle72.62%
Mike61.14%
Pete67.22%
Rob64.89%
Stuart69.21%
Total31%52%74%64%43%59.67%

Waitrose: No.1 Brown Butter with Cognac in graphs…

Graph Data:

2024
Total59.67%
Price£4.00
Looks31.11%
Sugar52.22%
Pastry73.89%
Filling63.89%
Value43.33%
2025
Total54.7%
Price£2.65
Looks28.95%
Sugar24.74%
Pastry73.68%
Filling59.16%
Value57.16%