2025WaitroseNo.1 Brown Butter with Cognac
- Looks
- 29%
- Sugar
- 25%
- Pastry
- 74%
- Filling
- 59%
- Value
- 57%
- Total
- 54.7%
The Ugliest Pie award for the worst looks.
The Dusting Disaster award for the worst sugar.
See the judges’ scores
| Judges | Looks | Sugar | Pastry | Filling | Value | Total |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Andy | 48.01% | |||||
| Claire | 62.05% | |||||
| Dave | 68.07% | |||||
| Emma | 69.77% | |||||
| Euan | 62.39% | |||||
| Fraser | 62.73% | |||||
| Heather | 39.72% | |||||
| Jade | 37.39% | |||||
| Jeff | 62.95% | |||||
| Katie | 44.89% | |||||
| Katy | 34.66% | |||||
| Kirsty | 21.70% | |||||
| Lewis | 72.73% | |||||
| Lucy | 38.01% | |||||
| Michelle | 36.59% | |||||
| Mike | 74.94% | |||||
| Pete | 63.92% | |||||
| Phil | 64.54% | |||||
| Rob | 74.20% | |||||
| Total | 29% | 25% | 74% | 59% | 57% | 54.70% |