2025M&SClassic

Looks
95%
Sugar
60%
Pastry
85%
Filling
100%
Value
80%
Total
86.14%
See the judges’ scores
JudgesLooksSugarPastryFillingValueTotal
Dave75.40%
Lewis96.88%
Total95%60%85%100%80%86.14%

2024M&SClassic

Looks
84%
Sugar
72%
Pastry
75%
Filling
82%
Value
76%
Total
77.78%
See the judges’ scores
JudgesLooksSugarPastryFillingValueTotal
Andy79.66%
Dave72.62%
Emma71.19%
Euan71.42%
Fraser90.00%
Heather74.26%
Jade65.63%
Jeff80.06%
Katie77.56%
Katy53.30%
Kirsty76.87%
Lewis92.56%
Lucy72.84%
Michelle75.91%
Mike94.03%
Pete92.56%
Rob76.76%
Stuart82.84%
Total84%72%75%82%76%77.78%

2022M&SClassic

Looks
77%
Sugar
74%
Pastry
86%
Filling
78%
Value
83%
Total
79.84%
See the judges’ scores
JudgesLooksSugarPastryFillingValueTotal
Andy95.40%
Dave66.59%
Euan92.84%
Fraser79.49%
Heather81.19%
Jade78.30%
Katie62.27%
Katy70.45%
Kirsty61.82%
Lewis86.36%
Pete90.91%
Rob92.50%
Total77%74%86%78%83%79.84%

2021M&SClassic

Looks
77%
Sugar
84%
Pastry
85%
Filling
86%
Value
89%
Total
84.94%
See the judges’ scores
JudgesLooksSugarPastryFillingValueTotal
Andy89.09%
Dave75.74%
Fraser73.69%
Heather83.18%
Jade74.26%
Katy84.66%
Kirsty94.89%
Lewis94.26%
Pete88.30%
Rob91.36%
Total77%84%85%86%89%84.94%

2020M&SClassic

Looks
65%
Sugar
83%
Pastry
90%
Filling
83%
Value
82%
Total
83.4%
See the judges’ scores
JudgesLooksSugarPastryFillingValueTotal
Emma BB88.01%
Emma S91.48%
Euan87.44%
Heather76.65%
Andy78.92%
Jade Mac82.27%
Keenan84.94%
Lewis81.76%
Mark70.06%
Michelle85.17%
Pete81.70%
Rob88.07%
Rosie87.73%
Total65%83%90%83%82%83.40%

2019M&SClassic

Looks
58%
Sugar
74%
Pastry
82%
Filling
81%
Value
75%
Total
77.53%
See the judges’ scores
JudgesLooksSugarPastryFillingValueTotal
Calum83.61%
Emma BB80.00%
Emma S62.39%
Euan90.91%
Heather87.50%
Jade83.80%
Keenan94.03%
Kirsty54.89%
Lewis82.62%
Marc63.41%
Michelle87.50%
Molly78.30%
Pete72.90%
Raymond87.50%
Rob54.15%
Ross76.96%
Total58%74%82%81%75%77.53%

2018M&SClassic

Looks
59%
Sugar
68%
Pastry
67%
Filling
85%
Value
73%
Total
73.08%
See the judges’ scores
JudgesLooksSugarPastryFillingValueTotal
Andrew59.20%
Emma Blair79.66%
Emma Stewart75.91%
Euan73.47%
Hannah72.62%
Heather71.08%
Jade76.59%
Lewis80.85%
Michelle78.24%
Pete70.00%
Raymond68.01%
Stephen Weir71.36%
Total59%68%67%85%73%73.08%

2017M&SClassic

Looks
59%
Sugar
60%
Pastry
64%
Filling
65%
Value
49%
Total
61.6%
See the judges’ scores
JudgesLooksSugarPastryFillingValueTotal
Andrew73.07%
Asa77.62%
Brian52.62%
Emma70.86%
Fraser55.17%
Stephen51.48%
Jade47.50%
Lewis37.45%
Mike72.62%
Niall69.15%
Pete70.06%
Total59%60%64%65%49%61.60%

M&S: Classic in graphs…

Graph Data:

2017
Total61.6%
Price£1.99
Looks59.09%
Sugar60%
Pastry63.64%
Filling65.45%
Value49.09%
2018
Total73.08%
Price£1.95
Looks59.17%
Sugar67.5%
Pastry66.67%
Filling85%
Value72.5%
2019
Total77.53%
Price£1.80
Looks57.81%
Sugar73.75%
Pastry82.19%
Filling81.13%
Value75.31%
2020
Total83.4%
Price£1.80
Looks65.38%
Sugar83.08%
Pastry90%
Filling83.08%
Value81.54%
2021
Total84.94%
Price£1.80
Looks77%
Sugar84%
Pastry85%
Filling86%
Value89%
2022
Total79.84%
Price£2.20
Looks76.67%
Sugar74.17%
Pastry85.83%
Filling77.5%
Value82.5%
2024
Total77.78%
Price£2.70
Looks84.44%
Sugar72.22%
Pastry75%
Filling82%
Value75.56%
2025
Total86.14%
Price£3.00
Looks95%
Sugar60%
Pastry85%
Filling100%
Value80%