2025AldiSpecially Selected

Looks
57%
Sugar
61%
Pastry
59%
Filling
66%
Value
66%
Total
62.35%
    See the judges’ scores
    JudgesLooksSugarPastryFillingValueTotal
    Andy67.10%
    Claire68.41%
    Dave61.14%
    Emma56.20%
    Heather52.22%
    Jade71.08%
    Jeff61.70%
    Katy75.57%
    Lewis50.05%
    Michelle63.69%
    Mike34.72%
    Pete66.36%
    Phil78.58%
    Rob66.07%
    Total57%61%59%66%66%62.35%

    2024AldiSpecially Selected

    Looks
    74%
    Sugar
    64%
    Pastry
    59%
    Filling
    70%
    Value
    71%
    Total
    66.05%
      See the judges’ scores
      JudgesLooksSugarPastryFillingValueTotal
      Andy80.85%
      Dave73.98%
      Emma59.71%
      Euan71.02%
      Fraser74.54%
      Heather79.66%
      Jade68.18%
      Jeff67.73%
      Katie57.04%
      Katy61.73%
      Kirsty59.60%
      Lewis68.01%
      Lucy63.92%
      Michelle46.65%
      Mike57.33%
      Pete73.13%
      Rob55.91%
      Stuart69.89%
      Total74%64%59%70%71%66.05%

      2021AldiSpecially Selected

      Looks
      55%
      Sugar
      29%
      Pastry
      58%
      Filling
      55%
      Value
      62%
      Total
      52.23%
      • The Dusting Disaster award for the worst sugar.
      See the judges’ scores
      JudgesLooksSugarPastryFillingValueTotal
      Andy68.64%
      Dave46.53%
      Fraser47.73%
      Heather55.74%
      Jade60.62%
      Katy53.86%
      Kirsty52.16%
      Lewis48.81%
      Pete49.37%
      Rob38.86%
      Total55%29%58%55%62%52.23%

      2020AldiSpecially Selected

      A bronze medal for 3rd place.
      Looks
      79%
      Sugar
      64%
      Pastry
      76%
      Filling
      77%
      Value
      78%
      Total
      74.84%
      • The Picture-Perfect Pie award for the best looks.
      See the judges’ scores
      JudgesLooksSugarPastryFillingValueTotal
      Andy88.30%
      Emma BB72.33%
      Emma S77.10%
      Euan71.99%
      Heather83.41%
      Jade Mac85.17%
      Keenan72.90%
      Lewis52.05%
      Mark80.85%
      Michelle82.84%
      Pete78.30%
      Rob76.59%
      Rosie51.14%
      Total79%64%76%77%78%74.84%

      2019AldiSpecially Selected

      Looks
      74%
      Sugar
      48%
      Pastry
      60%
      Filling
      49%
      Value
      64%
      Total
      55.71%
        See the judges’ scores
        JudgesLooksSugarPastryFillingValueTotal
        Calum51.42%
        Emma BB60.57%
        Emma S64.66%
        Euan37.38%
        Heather62.67%
        Jade63.98%
        Keenan65.80%
        Kirsty72.04%
        Lewis52.05%
        Michelle49.77%
        Molly53.75%
        Pete51.48%
        Raymond42.84%
        Rob59.15%
        Ross48.10%
        Total74%48%60%49%64%55.71%

        2018AldiSpecially Selected

        Looks
        67%
        Sugar
        72%
        Pastry
        71%
        Filling
        68%
        Value
        85%
        Total
        71.37%
          See the judges’ scores
          JudgesLooksSugarPastryFillingValueTotal
          Emma Blair63.98%
          Emma Stewart48.52%
          Euan73.98%
          Hannah40.57%
          Heather81.82%
          Jade75.68%
          Lewis89.77%
          Michelle73.98%
          Pete87.44%
          Raymond78.30%
          Stephen Weir71.08%
          Total67%72%71%68%85%71.37%

          Aldi: Specially Selected in graphs…

          Graph Data:

          2018
          Total71.37%
          Price£1.35
          Looks67.27%
          Sugar71.82%
          Pastry70.91%
          Filling68.18%
          Value84.55%
          2019
          Total55.71%
          Price£1.39
          Looks73.67%
          Sugar48%
          Pastry60%
          Filling48.67%
          Value64%
          2020
          Total74.84%
          Price£1.49
          Looks79.23%
          Sugar63.85%
          Pastry76.15%
          Filling76.92%
          Value78.46%
          2021
          Total52.23%
          Price£1.49
          Looks55%
          Sugar29%
          Pastry58%
          Filling55%
          Value62%
          2024
          Total66.05%
          Price£2.29
          Looks73.89%
          Sugar64.44%
          Pastry58.56%
          Filling69.67%
          Value70.83%
          2025
          Total62.35%
          Price£2.49
          Looks56.86%
          Sugar60.71%
          Pastry59.14%
          Filling66.14%
          Value65.71%